US and China continue AI race, but China leading NOW
Jack Kotin, Ben Armour, 4-6-2022, (economist, linguist, and fluent in five languages. He graduated with a Masters in International Economics and Finance, from Brandeis International Business School, and has worked as a market research analyst, project manager, and data analyst for GE, IBM, and Meituan Dianping and lawyer and freelance reporter, editor, and translator) "China, US Break Ahead of the Pack in Race for AI Hegemony," No Publication, https://www.the-yuan.com/271/China-US-Break-Ahead-of-the-Pack-in-Race-for-AI-Hegemony.html --MV
BOSTON AND LONDON - The rivalry that has been simmering between China and the United States, the world’s two leaders in developing artificial intelligence (AI) technology, is now nearing the boiling point as the two countries’ lines of battle become drawn ever more clearly in policy documents, white papers, and intelligence bulletins. The US has advantages such as leading hardware, research, and talent, whereas China has unparalleled masses of AI-ready data at its disposal to drive technological development, a strong will to succeed in its quest for primacy, and a head start in its already widespread deployment and adoption of many digital technologies. Since 2017, China has been producing more AI scholarly research than the US. But in 2020, for the first time, China also surpassed it in AI-related journal citations, according to last year’s Stanford University AI Index Report. “Citations measure whether the ideas you’re putting out are novel and have impact - not just that you have a lot of researchers pumping out publications,” said Michael Sellitto, Stanford University Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence deputy director and a member of its AI Index steering committee. “The data suggests that China is making more contributions to basic AI knowledge now, a qualitative improvement,” per the Stanford report. “I don’t think they’ll be number one, because I think there’s still a level of genius and creativity in Silicon Valley that persists and will always persist,” Breyer Capital founder Jim Breyer told CNBC, likening the two superpowers’ AI rivalry to the US-Soviet space race of the 1950s. In June 2020, San Francisco-based independent AI research lab OpenAI announced the launch of its GPT-3, the third generation of its massive Generative Pre-trained Transformer language model, which can write computer code, poetry, and everything in between, various media reported at the time. A year later, with considerably less ballyhoo, Tsinghua University’s Beijing Academy of Artificial Intelligence unveiled an even larger model, Wu Dao 2.0, with 10 times as many parameters - the neural network values that encode information. GPT-3 has 175 billion parameters, whereas Wu Dao 2.0’s creators claim that their model has 1.75 trillion. Not only can it generate text as GPT-3 does, but it can also generate images from text descriptions like OpenAI’s 12-billion parameter DALL-E model. Furthermore, it has a scaling strategy that is similar to Google’s 1.6 trillion-parameter Switch Transformer. Even as AI thus fuels the rivalry between China and the US, it also is driving the two countries far ahead of the rest of the world in innovation, economic growth, and national power, according to the Brookings Institution, a think tank based in Washington, DC. China’s official statements promoting the military-civil fusion of technological development to erode America’s competitive edge also prompt unease, which is further amplified by China’s grand trillion-dollar Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) infrastructure program that spans nearly 140 countries and is central to its plan to extend its global influence. The Digital Silk Road (DSR) is a key component of the BRI and seeks to reach into the digital sphere through the DSR’s main assets - fifth-generation wireless network communications technologies, mega data centers, AI, and satellite navigation systems - all of which have critical ramifications for data privacy, national security, and global cyberspace governance, and which will endow the Chinese with the power to access, analyze, and exploit the data of BRI recipient nations. Some worry this will also enable China to set global technological standards, according to the Brookings Institution. China’s actions have fed what Dean Garfield, president and chief executive of the Information Technology Industry Council, has denoted a new “hysteria” in Washington that America is ceding its innovation edge to China. Apropos of which, ex-Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice also said, “When we see [China]... say, ‘We’re going to do whatever it takes to surpass the United States’... you’re going to get a response from the United States,” per the Brookings report. Much of that response has been seeking to slow or arrest China’s progress by tightened screening of foreign investments in core technologies, scrutinizing academic exchanges, imposing tariffs to reduce China’s competitiveness in key sectors, increasing prosecutions of Chinese for economic espionage, and greater investment in counterintelligence. Arguments for ‘decoupling’ the economic relationship between the US and China by collapsing ICT supply chains would do just that. The US technology sector is deeply intertwined with China’s, with high-level collaboration between researchers and engineers and rising tallies of co-authored academic papers, and joint investments by US and Chinese venture capital firms into AI-related firms in both countries, Brookings said. In AI implementation in the civil sphere, China has greatly outpaced the West, open media platform China-US Focus reported last month. China instituted its Social Credit System in 2014 to monitor ordinary citizens and confer benefits or restrict privileges. The system is run on facial recognition and Big Data analysis powered by AI algorithms. China’s device market is also driving innovation, most notably in smartphones, cameras, robots, wearables, smart speakers, automotive, smart mirrors, and computer processors. With respect to US-China competition in the AI space, many US officials, among them Nicolas Chaillan, ex-chief software officer of the Air Force, fear the US may lose the AI race against China because the US is not funding critical AI projects as aggressively, per the China-US Focus report. In comparison to the more centralized Chinese research and development (R&D), most innovation in the US occurs in the private sector and is not directly aided by the government. This ‘decoupling’ or disconnect often creates delays and information gaps. The US still leads in military AI, but this may soon change as China continues to propel innovation with Big Data, digital surveillance, and cloud computing. The US holds leads in talent, research, development, and hardware, while China surpasses in implementation, as well as data quantity and quality, but in recent years China has succeeded in slowly leapfrogging the US and seems well positioned to overtake it in future. The first country to acquire an AI ‘strategic weapon’ will have a huge advantage in both security and the global economy, per the report. China’s cabinet the State Council announced a bold plan to push its AI sector in 2017, aiming to make the country the world's “major AI innovation center” by 2030. The slew of policies which various government departments have since issued on that basis have now coagulated into the edifice of the nation’s AI governance and support infrastructure.