Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US law limits private entities from hacking back – have to be cautious with private sectors

Jason Smith, 2-22-2022, Jason Smith currently serves as service chair and as assistant professor for security studies at the National War College. He has served as a leader and aviator in the US Coast Guard and the US Army, as advisor to the commandant of the Coast Guard, as senior policy advisor in the US Senate, and on the staff of the National Security Council. "Forget a Whole-of-Government Cybersecurity Strategy—It’s Time for a Whole-of-Nation Approach," Modern War Institute, https://mwi.usma.edu/forget-a-whole-of-government-cybersecurity-strategy-its-time-for-a-whole-of-nation-approach/ //jsam

Limitations to Offensive Public-Private Cybersecurity Partnerships

US law—specifically, 18 US Code § 1030—prevents private entities from hacking into another computer system. Proponents of hack-back policies find this law overly restrictive. Indeed, frustration with current policies has led to action by the government. Congress has introduced several pieces of legislation aimed at loosening restrictions on hacking back. Some advocates have gone even further by proposing modern day letters of marque authorizing certain companies or individuals to act on behalf of the government to disable or disrupt the attacking systems. Moreover, hacking back is not as simple as it seems and there are good arguments for a cautious approach. While proponents of authorizing the private sector to hack back typically also advocate for governmental oversite, it is unclear that the government has the capacity or the expertise to provide it. Indeed, Jason Healy and Robert Jervis have argued convincingly that US government departments and agencies involved in cybersecurity are rarely even able to maintain awareness of offensive cyber operations conducted by other US government departments and agencies. Additionally, attribution for cyberattacks is not easy. The bad guys often originate their attacks from innocent users’ machines they have taken over, employing bots, botnets, or zombies. Disabling or destroying the machines hurts innocent users (they are also victims of the hackers) and not the actual attackers. Imagine the potential harms if an attack was made to appear to have originated from a hospital’s IT network. Hacking back could result in real loss of life. Furthermore, while there is a lot of focus on offense and the ability to strike back, too much offense can create other problems, like instability in international relations. A back-and-forth exchange of cyberattacks between nation-states can spiral quickly beyond what either nation intended. What started out in the cyber world can escalate into brinkmanship and lethal force. In short, the United States is right to be cautious with empowering private entities to act offensively on behalf of the government. The past twenty years has demonstrated that the use of private military contractors comes with its own issues. Scandals surrounding Blackwater and other contractors has shown what happens when government allows privatization of inherent government functions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.