Only the perm solves – movements fail without showing credible political alternatives, and their anti-reformist ideological purity prevents true democracy.
Teivainen 5 [Teivo Teivainen, professor of World Politics at the University of Helsinki, “The World Social Forum: Arena or Actor?”, Chapter 11 in Charting transnational democracy : beyond global arrogance / edited by Janie Leatherman and Julie Webber, 2005, https://link.springer.com/book/10.1057/9781403981080]
Being anti-something can be politically useful, but only up to a point. The protesters of Seattle and similar events have been very effective in pointing out authoritarian aspects of the capitalist world-system. Even if various groups that have participated in these events do have programmatic statements for alternative futures, the way these events have been staged has not been very conducive in showing these futures to the world. The criticism of not being able to show a credible alternative, or any alternative at all, has become a problem for the legitimacy of the protest movements.
In most of the post-Seattle events, the protesters have often been labeled as “antiglobalization,” and some of them have used the expression themselves. 24 It would, however, be analytically faulty and politically unwise to simply define the movements as being against globalization, if the term is understood as the increasing transgression of nation-state borders on a worldwide level. Many of them are, I would claim, looking for a different kind of globalization, though some may prefer to use the older term internationalism. From a democratic perspective, the problem in some antiglobalization rhetoric is that one easily ends up with rather strange bedfellows. Professing antiglobalization pure and simple is not very helpful in terms of making a distinction between regulating the cross-border movements of speculative capital and those of black immigrants.
Outra globalização (another globalization) is an expression that has been emphasized by some of the key organizers of the Porto Alegre meetings (Grzybowski 1998; de Souza Santos 2001). Despite their insistence, the mass media in many parts of Latin America often talks of antiglobalization activists when referring to both Porto Alegre and some of the events inspired by it. The February 2001 protests related to a WEF regional meeting in Mexico and the March 2001 marches around the Inter- American Development Bank meeting in Santiago de Chile were the first big globalization-related protest events in Latin America after the first WSF, and the media coverage of them often referred to the Porto Alegre event as an important moment in the antiglobalization struggles.25
For those who want to argue for the possibility of a different kind of globalization, the risk of ending up with strange bedfellows is by no means absent. It is not always easy to see the differences, if any, of the “alternative” globalization proposals with the idea of many business leaders that some democratization is necessary in order to make the global expansion of capitalism acceptable (Falk and Strauss 2001). Those who cling to antiglobalization discourse are often right when they claim that the alternative globalization strategies would only lead to very moderate changes. Often, but not always.
It is frequently assumed that in the anti/alternative divide of globalization debates, being “anti” represents more radical and revolutionary options, whereas the “alternatives” are on the side of more superficial reforms. In terms of thinking about how to democratize the world, this assumption is not very helpful. Within the alternative globalization specter, it is possible to find and even easier to imagine such political projects that strive for a globalization that radically transforms the world. While antiglobalization people can be pro-capitalist, pro-globalization people may be anticapitalist.
Some of the debate and divide between the “anti” and the “alternative” is due to confused semantics or distorted categorizations. In order to fundamentally democratize the world, people who have chosen to regard globalization as a term that has been too polluted by its dominant usage and those who think it can still be given more progressive meanings can often work together. In principle, the WSF offers many opportunities for this to happen.