Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO is key for ensuring a western AI advantage BUT requires further guidelines and investment since its 2021 declaration.

Christie and Ertan 22 (Edward Hunter Christie is the owner and founder of AI Policy Consulting. He served as a NATO official from 2014 to 2020, ending his tenure in the role of Deputy Head of NATO’s Innovation Unit. Amy Ertan is a cybersecurity fellow at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs (Harvard Kennedy School), researcher at the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCDCOE) and doctoral candidate at the Information Security Group, Royal Holloway, University of London.) “NATO and Artificial Intelligence” 14 Jun 2022 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4133397 // ZX

NATO is a military alliance of democratic states in the North Atlantic region. Its first essential core task, unchanged since the Alliance’s creation in 1949, is collectively to deter and if necessary defend against armed attacks against any one of its members in the North Atlantic region, in line with Article 51 of the United Nations Charter. To ensure this primary task, Allied governments coordinate their defence policies to ensure a chosen degree of collective military interoperability, capability, and readiness. This is pursued through activities such as the definition and implementation of common military-technical standards, of commonly agreed military capability targets, and of common capability development activities and projects. At the organisational level, NATO has a permanent common military command structure which enables it, among other tasks, to uphold readiness, to organise exercises, and to lead collective military operations following relevant political decisions. NATO also pursues two additional core tasks in addition to collective defence, namely crisis management and cooperative security1, which leverage NATO’s nature and purpose as a military alliance. NATO’s purpose and structures imply a centrality of military considerations in how it approaches any new security challenge. NATO decisions are taken by consensus among Allied governments, through a multi-layered hierarchy of committees. The most senior committee, the North Atlantic Council (NAC), is a civilian committee. The NAC meets regularly at the level of Ambassadors, four times a year at the Ministerial level (twice Defence Ministers, twice Foreign Ministers), and on average every two years at the level of Heads of State and Government. In practice, NATO’s activities include consultations among Allied governments on matters of common interest, ranging from broad strategic discussions on international security developments to detailed decision-making on particular activities, projects, standards, targets, or policies. Warfare has always been shaped by technology. Artificial intelligence has already demonstrated the potential to enhance military capabilities and to create new military capabilities. From intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance to inclusion in unmanned systems, or across logistics and support functions, there are a number of consequences of AI inclusion across military domains that warrant attention and activity from NATO as an Alliance and as an organization. As noted by the STO, AI “has the potential for revolutionary impact on NATO operations and capabilities”, describing AI as a “fulcrum around which big data will be turned into actionable knowledge, and, ultimately, a NATO decision advantage” (2020, p.14). The STO further notes that “integration of AI into combat models & simulation, enterprise systems, decision support systems, cyber defence systems and autonomous vehicles will allow for rapid and more effective human-machine decision making” (2020, p.15). The formulation of AI policies for the area of defence is a recent but fast-moving area of work. At the time of writing, the United States and France were the only Allies with published national AI defence strategies (US Department of Defense, 2018; French Ministry of the Armed Forces, 2019), with the UK announcing their intention to release a defence-focused AI strategy, see UK Ministry of Defence (2021: p.42), likely before the end of 2021. At NATO, the International Staff produced two policy White Papers for the consideration of Allied governments in the course of 2020, one on Artificial Intelligence, the other on Autonomous Technologies more specifically. In October 2021, NATO Defence Ministers approved NATO’s first-ever AI Strategy, as well as a related Data Exploitation Policy (NATO, 2021a). These policy documents will be discussed in sections 4 and 5 below, with a main focus on the AI Strategy. Iterative development refers to the fact that software development in general, and AI development in particular, requires highly iterative and dynamic work processes that are generally referred to as Agile development. From a project management perspective, traditional development generally follows a Waterfall model, a linear process where each step is completed before moving on to the next step. Agile development, by contrast, allows for development steps to be revisited and adjusted multiple times in a more dynamic manner, with much shorter development and testing timelines. The need to adopt Agile development approaches is well understood in key parts of the NATO Enterprise, notably Allied Command Transformation (ACT) and the NATO Communications and Information Agency (NCIA), and in many national defence institutions. What is less clear is what types of reforms need to be enacted at higher organisational levels. Access to data refers to a range of organisational and normative challenges to ensure that Allied defence institutions can leverage the data they have as effectively as possible. To address these challenges, a NATO Data Exploitation Policy was developed, based on detailed consultations with internal NATO Enterprise stakeholders and with representatives of Allied governments. The Policy is based on the recognition of the need for a comprehensive life-cycle approach to data resources (including collection, documentation, storage, exploitation, retention, and disposal) and for the further development of relevant enabling factors for each lifecycle stage. NATO’s emerging data policy efforts also include the formulation of guiding principles that partly mirror the principles of responsible use that should hold for AI, with the addition of specific considerations that relate to data ownership and management. To the extent that the NATO Enterprise carries out its own data exploitation and AI development efforts, the relevant NATO staffs will need the relevant structures, resources, and staff to do so, in a manner that mirrors what occurs in national defence institutions. Additional considerations are necessary to ensure that the NATO Enterprise can play a full role as a facilitator for common multinational and Alliance-wide efforts. A particularly salient issue in that context is the collaborative training of Machine Learning algorithms. While individual Allies may choose in many cases to remain the sole owners and custodians of the real-world military data they collect, there is a good case for seeking economies of scale and scope through collaborative data exploitation and algorithm training efforts. Intuitively, one may expect this to imply a need to pool datasets from multiple institutions under the custodianship of a single entity, for example a NATO body. This need not necessarily be the case, thanks to the existence of technical solutions that allow for the collaborative development of Machine Learning algorithms based on sharing successive trained instances of algorithms without actual data pooling. However, significant practical work will be necessary to ensure that the Alliance is able to pursue both types of effort – informally, data sharing versus model sharing – in efficient and seamless ways

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.