Plan builds trust by solidifying legal principles – coop solves
Hill ‘20 [Steven Hill, served until February 2020 as Legal Adviser and Director of the Office of Legal Affairs (OLA) at the NATO International Staff, "AI's Impact on Multilateral Military Cooperation: Experience from NATO," 4-27-2020, American Journal of International Law | Cambridge Core, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-journal-of-international-law/article/ais-impact-on-multilateral-military-cooperation-experience-from-nato/3AEF22AA22550A10B75DD74A806D4D18]/lf
Conclusion: The Need for Multinational Dialogue As noted above, the different national strategies refer to the need for legal and ethical frameworks. They also generally refer to the desirability of multilateral cooperation on AI. The limited work within NATO so far has also pointed to a willingness to take on these issues in a multinational setting. However, the reality is that these discussions have not yet taken off. There may be good reasons for this, including the ongoing nature of LAWS discussions in Geneva or the understandable reluctance—frequently encountered with respect to new technologies—to take positions that could constrain innovation or that could present a strategic disadvantage to those who abide by the rules. At the same time, the perception that there are unresolved legal or ethical issues hovering over military applications of AI clearly poses a risk to the use of this technology, including in a multilateral military setting. There is generally broad agreement among NATO allies that existing international law should apply to the military use of new technologies, including AI. However, a perception of lack of clarity on the rules of the game may lead to a lack of trust that might hamper multinational cooperation. In this regard, dialogue about legal and ethical frameworks can be an important means of building trust. Individual NATO Allies are in the midst of developing their own national strategies for military applications of AI. As noted above, while these strategies use some of the same vocabulary in calling for more clarity on the legal and ethical frameworks of military AI, there is a real risk of a lack of meeting of the minds about the substantive content of these frameworks. Consider but one of the issues that will arise: the potential scope of difference of views related to data ownership, sharing, and use.18 If data is “fuel” for AI, the question of who owns it and under what conditions it can be shared and used by others is of strategic importance. Despite the sense that like-minded countries will need to cooperate to develop their own sources of such “fuel,” there is no agreed transatlantic approach in policy and law on how to handle a wide range of data-related legal issues. Data sharing arrangements need to be in place beyond the limited, generally law enforcement-related sectors in which there are existing arrangements. There is considerable work to be done to create the necessary trust to develop mutually-agreed procedures that strike the balance between the many different equities involved in such an exchange of information. While most of these discussions on data take place outside of NATO, NATO does have some experience that could be relevant. For example, NATO already has in place mechanisms for the secure sharing of information that are based on trust built over the life of a seventy-year-old Alliance. NATO has recently built upon these practices to promote the sharing of evidence gathered in battlefield settings for use in the criminal prosecutions of foreign terrorist fighters.19 Achieving consensus agreement on these initiatives required a considerable amount of legal dialogue for Allies to find a pragmatic way forward, building on NATO’s tradition of “legal interoperability.”20 In the end, NATO’s early-days experience shows that in a multinational setting, it is important to understand AI-enabled military applications and to support their implementation in practical contexts. This requires open dialogue between Allies and other partners as well as with industry. NATO has the potential to play a unique role in this process