Allies misrepresent their actual preference to gain leverage, but overshoot, producing gridlock
Dr. Ping-Kuei Chen 16, Doctor of Philosophy in Government and Politics from the University of Maryland, "Holding Hands While Parting Ways: Examining Alliance Treaty Renegotiation", Doctoral Dissertation, 2016, https://drum.lib.umd.edu/bitstream/handle/1903/18546/Chen_umd_0117E_17257.pdf?sequence=1
During bargaining, alliance members interact and communicate their demands for future security cooperation. Allies not only try to determine a set of mutually acceptable solutions, but also evaluate whether the alliance is worth preserving. In the attempt to find a solution to their differences, members may encounter difficulties during negotiation, since their interests are unlikely to overlap completely.
Morrow (1994) suggests that two problems may hinder coordination in alliance politics. First, a distributional problem occurs when members have different preferences among all available solutions. The other problem is informational problem. Allies may conceal available options from each other in order to advance their own interests. These two problems intertwine. As Morrow argues, “Distributional interests prevent the honest sharing of information.” This dictum applies to intra-alliance bargaining because, even in a security alliance, members are not fully aware of each other’s intentions. Members sometimes have an incentive to misrepresent or hide their true intent in terms of maximizing their own security benefit, and so may withhold information regarding their security interests or falling short of their commitments in order to achieve unexpressed policy goals.
These distributional and informational problems give rise to three predicaments during intra-alliance bargaining: alliance members may (1) be unaware that they have an interest divergence; (2) acknowledge the existence of interest divergence, but be uncertain about a mutually acceptable solution; or (3) be unsure whether other members will keep their commitments in the future.
To overcome these difficulties, allies rely on information revealed during intraalliance bargaining when deciding on the future of an alliance. First, both sides need to recognize the existence of interest divergence and the need for a solution. Bargaining needs to focus on clarifying the problem when one or more partners fail even to see it, and sometimes this act of clarification can in fact be the most difficult discussion involved in bargaining.
Second, if both members recognize the interest divergence, they can move on to negotiate an arrangement. Successful bargaining requires allies to agree on one among a set of mutually acceptable options. A distributional problem may occur, however, when allies have uncertainties regarding each other’s updated security interests and hence regarding what arrangements might satisfy these interests. Dialogue can clarify matters, but a member may become suspicious about the claims that an ally makes if these claims differ from its own reading of the situation. Since an alliance relationship allows allies to interact more frequently, each ally is confident of its own understanding of the evolving security needs of its partners. When there is a perception gap among members concerning the security benefit that one or another enjoys or about the kind of cooperation that best furthers the alliance’s common interests, agreement may be difficult to reach. Allies must genuinely communicate their own preferences and be able to verify each other’s claims.
Finally, members naturally want to know the extent to which the other members value and are committed to the alliance. When their security interests have changed, they will not agree to negotiate unless they still consider each other reliable. When members agree to revise a treaty, a major goal is to ensure that any new obligations will induce sustained cooperation. An alliance will soon fall apart if bargaining reveals that a member has no interest in maintaining it.
When allies are consistently candid during renegotiation, their differences are likely to be resolved. However, as mentioned in the context of studies of burden sharing, allies have incentives to take advantage of their partners that are founded on the assumption that the interests of the latter in maintaining the alliance will lead them to grant concessions during negotiations as a means to salvage the imperiled relationship. In other words, some members may enter into renegotiation with the belief that abrogation would be too costly for the other members. In addition, an uncommitted partner is unlikely to engage in negotiation and more likely simply to abandon the alliance immediately. A member that is willing to renegotiate, by contrast, still values and therefore seeks to preserve the alliance. Each member thus starts bargaining under the assumption that the others are unlikely to give up easily, a situation that leaves rooms for allies to misrepresent their security interests and levels of commitment.
Even in an alliance relationship, a member’s commitment to the alliance is private information. Both the challenger and the partner have an incentive to misrepresent their true intentions in the pursuit of leverage during bargaining. Expressing discontent may gain concessions from other allies as well as testing the loyalty of each. A challenger may, in the course of renegotiation, threaten to withdraw from the alliance when it is in fact willing to accept an arrangement; a partner may misjudge a challenger’s resolve and fail to accommodate its needs; a challenger may misperceive its partner as dissatisfied and decide to withdraw from the alliance preemptively. Therefore, even though intra-alliance bargaining stands a good chance, and may represent the only chance, of resolving disagreement among members, there is no guarantee that this process will succeed.