Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Just informing NATO undermines cohesion --- only genuine consultation can limit tension among members

Lorenz, 20 --- international security expert at the Polish Institute of International Affairs [Wojciech, November, 2020, “Strengthening NATO’s cohesion through consultation”, https://icds.ee/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/ICDS_Brief_NATO2030_-Series_1_Wojciech_Lorenz_November-2020_cor.pdf, accessed 6/23/22, NB]

NATO has been able to adapt to profound changes in international relations largely due to its consultation mechanisms. During the Cold War, consultation enabled NATO to adjust its strategy to the Allies’ changing perceptions of the threat posed by the Soviet Union. After the Cold War, consultations facilitated NATO’s adjustment to new threats that required out-of- area interventions and engagement in the fight against terrorism. Today, the Alliance is again trying to adjust to a new reality. With US policy in NATO likely to be determined by the rise of China, the Allies will have to consult to come up with a coherent approach to reconcile US global and European regional security interests.

NATO was created as a collective defence organisation soon after World War II to counterbalance the power of the Soviet Union. The Alliance’s military credibility was guaranteed by the economic, political and military potential of the US and supported by American military presence in Europe. In case of military attack, the Allies could invoke Article 5 of the Washington Treaty to trigger a collective military response. The credibility of this mutual security guarantee has been strengthened by consultation mechanisms. Article 4 of the Washington Treaty gives Allies the right to call for consultations if their “territorial integrity, political independence or security ... is threatened.”1 Rather than rely on ad hoc consultations during crisis, NATO created the North Atlantic Council—its main decision making body, which meets at least weekly at the level of permanent representatives (ambassadors) and regularly at higher political levels (foreign ministers, ministers of defence and heads of state and government). Over the years, NATO has developed habits, norms and institutional mechanisms that enable almost continuous consultations on the whole range of issues affecting their security. These have facilitated the development of a common strategy and necessary capabilities to support it, and limited tensions among member states with sometimes differing national interests, strengthening the Alliance’s political cohesion. As NATO decisions are made by consensus, the consultation agenda also has to be approved by all Allies. Informal discussion among various groups of states and the weekly informal lunch of all representatives can help to build a consensus on what should be discussed during formal meetings, perhaps leading to politically binding decisions

THE COLD WAR ERA

The 1956 report of three ministers (the ‘Three Wise Men’) offered clear practical suggestions for consultation, stating that it “means discussion of problems collectively, in the early stages of policy formation, and before national positions become fixed.”2 The report significantly influenced the development of NATO’s consultation norms. It made clear that consultations are not about informing other Allies about decisions that have already been taken, but entail frank discussion and the possibility of influencing national choices that affect mutual security.3

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.