Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Genuine consultation can overcome differences and produce coordinated responses

Lorenz, 20 --- international security expert at the Polish Institute of International Affairs [Wojciech, November, 2020, “Strengthening NATO’s cohesion through consultation”, https://icds.ee/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/ICDS_Brief_NATO2030_-Series_1_Wojciech_Lorenz_November-2020_cor.pdf, accessed 6/23/22, NB]

Although Allies will always have some different interests, they can use consultations to limit their negative, political impact. They can also adjust consultation mechanisms to changing strategic realities, further limiting the risk of tensions and increasing the probability of a common, coordinated response. The Allies should thus agree a set of principles to guide their consultations in the coming decade. These might include:

• Consultations must not be merely notifications or briefings about decisions already taken. They must entail frank discussions and the chance to influence an Ally’s actions.

• Consultations with Allies should always precede discussions with rivals.

• Allies must consult before they take any decision that could undermine the credibility of collective defence.

• When time permits, Allies should consult on actions out-of-area, which could affect NATO security.

• When Allies agree on common actions out-of- area, there must be full consultations on matters that may affect the common mission.

Allies can also take measures to influence their cost-benefit calculations regarding timely discussions of crucial issues. They should:

• Commit, in a highly visible political declaration, to observe agreed norms.

• Formally assess whether the norms of NATO consultations, which require frank discussion on matters affecting collective defence, have been violated. This will be necessary to restore confidence in the consultation mechanism in its most important dimension and to limit the risk of future unilateral actions.

Create an incentive for consultations on issues that extend beyond collective defence. Even though support for out-of-area actions cannot be guaranteed, Allies could commit to not publicly criticise the actions of an Ally that has used the consultation mechanism.

Small- and medium-sized countries, including the Baltic states and Poland would be the biggest beneficiaries of enhanced consultations. It is in their clear interest to use consultation to strengthen NATO’s political cohesion.

The Allies should also consider recasting their NATO+1 bilateral relations with partners from the Asia-Pacific region (Australia, South Korea, Japan, New Zealand) as a new NATO+4 multilateral cooperation format, perhaps branded the NATO-Pacific Forum.11 Regular consultations would provide Allies and partners with better situational awareness about evolving threats from both China and Russia, facilitating a coordinated response in numerous areas, including cyber, space or arms control.

Some Allies might wish to promote a reset with Russia under the pretext of not pushing it into an alliance with China. This would not be in the interests of the Baltic states and Poland, as any reset would inevitably be at the expense of credible collective defence and deterrence in Europe. NATO+4 consultations would, in exploring the common strategic goals of China and Russia in undermining the rules-based international order, limit the risk that Allies would view a Russia reset as a simple answer to a complex problem, and facilitate a discussion on effective responses to the challenges posed by both Russia and China as part of a broader NATO strategy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.