NATO expansion will generate internal pressure on Putin to change course and moderate its foreign policy
Mitchell, 22 – senior advisor for the Russia and Europe Center at USIP [A. Wess, May 26,United States Institute of Peace, “Putin’s War Backfires as Finland, Sweden Seek to Join NATO; The Russian autocrat aimed to check NATO’s expansion but has instead strengthened the alliance,” https://www.usip.org/publications/2022/05/putins-war-backfires-finland-sweden-seek-join-nato, Acc 6/23/22, HO]
What are the short-term implications of NATO expansion, specifically for the war in Ukraine? Could it prolong the war or compel Putin to take desperate measures, like deploying WMDs?
The decision by Finland and Sweden to apply for NATO membership demonstrates the unintended consequences for Putin of his war in Ukraine. While his immediate objective was to defeat and subjugate Ukraine, he also wanted to create a kind of demonstration effect of Russian strength and, as the pre-war Russian diplomatic note made plain, push NATO back from Russia’s borders. The war has achieved exactly the opposite. Now, Russia will have even more NATO presence on its borders, both through the addition of hundreds of miles of NATO territory to the Russian frontier, and through the deployment of Western troop presence in Central Europe. So, the war is backfiring for Putin not only militarily but geopolitically.
The immediate implication is that Putin will have to give military attention to Russia’s northwestern flank at a moment when he needs all the firepower he can muster for the conflict in Ukraine. Rather than prolonging the war, if anything, NATO’s Nordic expansion could shorten it by increasing the military demands on Russia. Politically, it may increase the pressure on Putin from within the Russian elite to alter course, since it is a further illustration, alongside the effects of sanctions and losses in the war itself, of the costs of his aggressive foreign policy. Remember, Putin’s central value proposition, and the key to his legitimacy in the eyes of the Russian elite, is his claim to military competence — specifically, the ability to be able to rebuild Russian power and prestige by the effective use of the military. If the war exposes that as a fiction, as it is now doing, and also amasses sufficient geopolitical, economic and political costs along the way, then Putin’s value proposition as a leader is seriously eroded in Kremlin circles, and among the Russian populace as well.