Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Ukraine conflict limits Putin’s likely response to NATO membership --- signs of aggression will just solidify NATO

Mitchell, 22 – senior advisor for the Russia and Europe Center at USIP [A. Wess, May 26,United States Institute of Peace, “Putin’s War Backfires as Finland, Sweden Seek to Join NATO; The Russian autocrat aimed to check NATO’s expansion but has instead strengthened the alliance,” https://www.usip.org/publications/2022/05/putins-war-backfires-finland-sweden-seek-join-nato, Acc 6/23/22, HO]

Aside from immediate measures and threats (e.g., cutting off energy supplies to Finland, Putin’s threat of a “technical military” response), how do you expect Putin to respond if Finland and Sweden formally join NATO?

Putin’s dilemma is that he has to respond in some way to Finland’s and Sweden’s NATO moves to avoid seeming weak, yet he has few obvious or effective response options. For years he has threatened both countries that joining NATO would lead to negative consequences, so he can’t afford to not respond in some fashion. The easiest response is to cut energy exports, as he has done. But both countries can diversify energy sources without excessively straining their economies. Militarily, Putin’s usual response would be to send Russian conventional forces to the border with Finland and to deploy Russian planes and ships to the eastern Baltic. But he needs all the military power he can get in Ukraine.

So, Putin’s most likely response will be to deploy missiles to the border with Finland and to Kaliningrad. Russia possesses a large nuclear arsenal, including numerous low-yield, or tactical, nuclear weapons. Putin is likely to deploy such weapons in a way that plays to Finnish and Swedish fears that entering NATO will trigger an aggressive Russian response. He is aware that there are strong pacifist traditions in both countries. In the old days, stoking those dynamics by aggressive moves to create pressure on Finnish and Swedish governments might have had its desired effect. But doing so now is only likely to increase Finnish and Swedish support for NATO membership, given what they’ve seen happening in Ukraine. That’s what war does — it creates fear, and fear leads peaceful nations to seek security through alliances.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.