Enhancing the JAIC is necessary for solvency – they coordinate across different services and maintain focus on the message and mission for AI
Tarraf, Shelton, Parker 2019 - Senior Information Scientist, Senior Engineer, and physical Scientist at the RAND Corporation [ Danielle C., William, Edward, et al RAND Cooperation, “The Department of Defense Posture for Artificial Intelligence”, file:///Users/MiraAgarwal/Downloads/RAND_RR4229%20(2).pdf, Acc 6/18/22, M.A.]
Organization We begin by revisiting DoD’s vision for AI and the means of achieving that vision. As we noted in Chapter Four, there is a lack of clarity about the raison d’être of the JAIC, and how the specific mandate and roles it has been assigned—and the visibility and authorities it has been given—support that. DoD needs to be consistent in its intent, actions, and messaging. Our first strategic recommendation therefore addresses DoD’s vision for AI and the governance structures that would support this vision, as articulated in the DoD AI strategy. Recommendation S-1: DoD should adapt AI governance structures that align authorities and resources with the mission of scaling AI. 66 The Department of Defense Posture for Artificial Intelligence As we noted in Chapter Four, DoD’s vision for AI and the scale, urgency, and unity of efforts conveyed in that vision are at odds with the visibility, authorities, and resources it has provided to the JAIC— the focal point of DoD AI. DoD needs to develop governance and organizational structures that align authorities and resources with its vision of scaling AI across DoD. The insights gathered from our industry interviews and the supporting change management literature (see section “Industry: Organization” in Appendix C) lead us to believe there is value in, if not strict necessity of, a centralized effort supported at the highest levels with long-term funding commitments to institute organizational change and scale AI across DoD. Indeed, one of our industry interviewees even noted that centralization at onset was key to their organization’s success, and premature decentralization of effort would have likely been detrimental (see section “Industry: Organization” in Appendix C).1 Starting from that premise, we highlight two possible options for organizational and governance structures, and the rationale for them, although noting that other options might be viable as well, subject to further study. The first option would likely require congressional support to execute, while the second can be executed without, as it aligns with current DoD procedures and organizational structures. Option 1: Enhance the visibility and authorities of the JAIC to enable it to carry out its mission of scaling AI and its impact across DoD, including budgetary and workforce authorities over the military services. Option 2: Take a two-pronged organizational approach as follows: • Establish a JAIC council chaired by the JAIC director and consisting of one AI leadership representative from each service.2 1 We note that this comment, and those of other industry interviewees, imply that if the effort to scale AI across an organization is successful, its natural ending point might be the sunset of the centralized entity that drove the transformation as AI capabilities are diffused across the organization. We therefore expect the JAIC’s role to evolve, though we expect that to happen along a longer timeline (ten or more years), based on our assessment of the state of AI technologies in Chapter Three. 2 Regardless of which governance structure is instituted, if any, establishment of a JAIC council, as described, could facilitate coordination between the JAIC and the services. Recommendations 67 • Establish or reinforce a centralized AI coordination and investment organization within each of the services, with appropriate visibility and authorities, to facilitate scaling AI and its impact across the service, and to promote mandated coordination with the JAIC. In either option: • The DSD should provide the JAIC director with opportunities, at least annually, to present and be heard at the Deputy’s Management Action Group (DMAG) forum (or whichever Deputy Secretary–level forum performs the functions of the DMAG). 3 The rationale for Option 1 is as follows: There is evidence to support that DoD has taken the right approach in establishing the JAIC as a centralized focal point for DoD’s AI strategy (see Chapter 4, Organization). The evidence also suggests that the JAIC, pending initial success, will need to continue in that role for several years because of the expected timeline for AI deployment across enterprise, missionsupport, and operational AI (Chapter Three).