Global cooperation on AI safety is key to avoiding the most dangerous AI technology
Green et al., 2019 - Director of technology ethics at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics [Brian Patrick et al., Big Data and Cognitive Computing, “Global Solutions vs. Local Solutions for the AI Safety Problem,” https://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/global-solutions-vs-local-ai-safety-problem/docview/2546937568/se-2, 6/18/22 MD]
4.4.2. Ways to Affect a Race to Create the First AI An AI creation race is generally regarded as bad because it encourages the creation of the least-safe AIs first. A war between AIs may also become possible if several AIs are created simultaneously [64,65]. There are many ideas on how to affect an AI race in order to make it safer, that is, to lower the probability of creating dangerous AI. As a race with many participants is a very complex game, there are not obvious ways to predict how it will react to seemingly good interventions, for example, openness. Bostrom has shown that if no one knows the capabilities of others and their own capabilities, it will slow down the race, so openness about capabilities may be dangerous [66]. Actions that may affect an AI race and make it safer may include: Changing the number of participants. Increasing or decreasing information exchange and level of openness. Reducing the level of enmity between organizations and countries, and preventing conventional arms races and military buildups. Increasing the level of cooperation, coordination, and acceptance of the idea of AI safety among AI researchers. Changing the total amount of funding available. Promoting intrinsic motivations for safety. Seth Baum discussed the weakness of monetary incentives for beneficial AI designs, and cautions: “One recurrent finding is that monetary incentives can reduce intrinsic motivation” [67]; when the money is gone, people lose motivation. Baum also noted that the mere fact that a law existed promoted obedience in some situations and that social encouragement can increase intrinsic motivation. Changing social attitudes toward the problem and increasing awareness of the idea of AI safety. Trying to affect the speed of the AI race, either slowing it down or accelerating it in just one place by concentrating research. It is interesting to note that acceleration could be done locally, but slowing it would require global cooperation, and so is less probable. Affecting the idea of the AI race as it is understood by the participants [67]: if everybody thinks that the winner takes everything, the race is more dangerous. A similar framing solution has been suggested in the field of bioweapons, that is, to stop claiming bioweapon creation is easy, as it might become attractive to potential bioterrorists. In fact, bioweapons are not as easy to develop and deploy as is shown in movies, and would probably kill the terrorists first [68].