CBMs prevent global conflicts from autonomous systems – AI expansion is inevitable. Only US leadership can promote Safe expansion
Horowitz, 2021 - Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania [Michael Horowitz, 1-26-2021, , Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, "How Joe Biden can use confidence-building measures for military uses of AI” https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/00963402.2020.1860331 accessed on 6-18-2022]
Autonomous naval ships, algorithms to interpret drone video footage – the US military and other armed forces around the world are thinking about how to incorporate applications of artificial intelligence systems into their operations. The Biden administration has an opportunity to foster international cooperation on military AI to reduce the risk of inadvertent conflict while still pursuing US military leadership. Perhaps no technology holds global imagination concerning the future of military power more than artificial intelligence (AI), in both positive and negative ways. Anticipating the impact of AI systems on the security environment, in 2018, the United States Department of Defense launched the Joint Artificial Intelligence Center (JAIC). The JAIC is one of several US military initiatives designed “to seize upon the transformative potential of Artificial Intelligence technology” (DOD 2019) and assist the American military in preparing for future wars filled with autonomous systems and algorithms. While it is still true that most military uses of AI are closer to concept than reality, many countries, including Russia and China – competitors seeking to challenge US conventional military superiority – are seeking to incorporate ever-greater levels of autonomy into their military operations. It will be a busy four years on the military AI front. President-elect Joe Biden’s administration will have to make critical choices about what strategy to pursue regarding the international governance of military AI. These choices will be key to ensuring that, even as the US military invests heavily in AI, these investments promote, rather than undermine, global stability. Competition for AI leadership is inevitable, and it is important not to exaggerate the potential for cooperation, but countries should have shared interests in preventing accidents or inadvertent war emerging from uses of AI. Confidence-building measures, best known from the Cold War, such as an AI equivalent to the Incidents at Sea Agreement, could decrease the likelihood that military uses of AI increase the risk of conflict.
US dialogue with allies about AI safety is a confidence building measure that addresses the risk of accidental conflicts and mistaken escalation
Horowitz and Kahn, 2021 – Senior and Research Fellows at the Council on Foreign Relations [Michael and Lauren, The Washington Quarterly 3-19-2021 “Leading in Artificial Intelligence through Confidence Building Measures” TM]
The role of artificial intelligence (AI) in military use has been the subject of intense debates in the national security community in recent years— not only the potential for AI to reshape capabilities, but also the potential for unintentional conflict and escalation. For many analysts, fear that military applications of AI would lead to increased risk of accidents and inadvertent escalation looms large, regardless of the potential benefits. Those who are concerned can cite a plethora of potential ways things can go awry with algorithms: brittleness, biased or poisoned training data, hacks by adversaries, or just increased speed of decision-making leading to fear-based escalation. Yet, given its importance for the future of military power, it is imperative that the United States moves forward with responsible speed in designing, integrating, and deploying relevant military applications of AI. How should the United States simultaneously pursue AI swiftly while reducing the risk of unintentional conflict or escalation in the United States or elsewhere? The answer may lie in US leadership to promote responsible norms and standards of behavior for AI as part of a series of confidence-building measures (CBMs) tailored to reduce the likelihood of these scenarios. Four CBMs in particular could be fertile grounds for cooperation. First, the United States could promote dialogues with Russia and China, integrating discussions of AI into ongoing strategic stability talks with both nations. Second, the United States could announce norms of responsible behavior for military applications of AI and pursue a multilateral code of conduct surrounding those norms. Even if signatories are primarily democratic allies and partners, it could nevertheless make a powerful statement about where the United States stands and help to isolate those nations that opt-out. Third, the United States could declare that it will always keep a human-in-the-loop (HITL) when it comes to the use of nuclear weapons and invite other nuclear powers to commit to the same. Finally, the United States could lead the negotiation of an Autonomous Incidents Agreement—similar to the Incidents-at-Sea Agreement during the Cold War—designed to decrease the risk that the deployment of AI-enabled autonomous systems could create uncertainty or surprise that leads to unintentional conflict or inadvertent escalation. Given the interests that all nations have in avoiding unintentional conflict, CBMs focused in this area—where the United States and its competitors have shared interests—could prove effective. Moreover, CBMs can serve as building blocks for cooperation by enhancing mutual understanding and therefore trust.1 By focusing on CBMs that commit the United States to actions that it could pursue independently regardless, the United States can further ensure that, even if cooperation does not materialize, it is not constrained in its efforts to be a world leader in AI. US leadership internationally could therefore help the United States create a safer military AI future without undermining American efforts to leverage AI for military purposes.