Expanding TEVV helps reduce the risk of Chinese and Russian AI – confidence building measure reduce pressures that cause crisis instability. Even if they do not model, US action alone reduces the risk.
Scharre 2021 – Director of the Technology and National Security Program at the Center for a New American Security [Paul, 6/28/21,https://tnsr.org/2021/06/debunking-the-ai-arms-race-theory/, “Debunking the AI Arms Race Theory”, 6/18/22, LND]
The National Security Commission on AI has demonstrated what such an approach might look like in practice. The commission’s 700-plus page report issued sweeping recommendations for enhancing U.S. competitiveness in AI and military adoption, but also dedicated an entire chapter to “Autonomous Weapon Systems and Risks Associated with AI-Enabled Warfare.”70 With regards to safety concerns, the report acknowledged: Russia and China are likely to field AI-enabled systems that have undergone less rigorous TEVV than comparable U.S. systems and may be unsafe or unreliable … The United States should … highlight how deploying unsafe systems could risk inadvertent conflict escalation [and] emphasize the need to conduct rigorous TEVV.71 The commission issued a number of recommendations to mitigate the risks of AI competition, including improving Defense Department TEVV processes and working with allies to develop “international standards of practice for the development, testing, and use of AI-enabled and autonomous weapon systems” to reduce the risk of accidents.72 Recently, the Defense Department has taken positive steps toward emphasizing AI safety and improving TEVV processes. In May 2021, Deputy Secretary of Defense Kathleen Hicks issued a memorandum on implementing “Responsible AI.” The memo launched a series of internal bureaucratic structures, including “establishing a test and evaluation and verification and validation framework that integrates real-time monitoring, algorithm confidence metrics, and user feedback to ensure trusted and trustworthy AI capabilities.”73 Additionally, in public comments Hicks emphasized the importance of AI “safety.”74 These are important and valuable steps toward establishing the necessary bureaucratic processes to ensure U.S. military AI systems are robust and reliable as well as setting a constructive tone publicly. The United States has been active in promulgating norms about the responsible use of military AI. A deliberate approach toward acknowledging and mitigating the risks of AI competition need not come at the expense of adopting AI to improve military effectiveness. Ideally, a frank assessment of the risks of AI competition and U.S. transparency about measures it is taking to mitigate these risks would open the door to cooperative measures among competitors. There may be a variety of confidence-building measures that states could adopt to reduce the risks of AI competition.75 “Track II” dialogues among academic experts to better understand these risks and potential cooperative measures are already underway. Future direct government-to-government dialogues could explore whether there is opportunity for common ground. Cooperative measures to reduce risk will depend on other states such as Russia and China engaging in good faith. However, there is no guarantee that they will do so. What the United States can do is improve its own internal processes for AI TEVV and for ensuring human responsibility. The United States should also publicly articulate why it would be in other states’ best interests to cooperate to avoid some of these mutual risks. Even as the United States adopts AI to improve its national defense, it should take measures — and incentivize others to do so as well — to ensure military AI systems are safe and that warfare remains under effective human control.