The DOD has a history of pushing out technology prematurely
Scharre 2021 – Director of the Technology and National Security Program at the Center for a New American Security [Paul, 6/28/21,https://tnsr.org/2021/06/debunking-the-ai-arms-race-theory/, “Debunking the AI Arms Race Theory”, 6/18/22, LND]
That militaries may incur risks from moving too quickly in adopting new technology is counter to the common caricature of military culture as conservative, hidebound, and resistant to innovation. While this caricature is not entirely fair — militaries do innovate even in peacetime49 — the lack of direct, observational feedback on performance in a realistic competitive environment, akin to marketplace dynamics for commercial companies, can mean that militaries are often slow to adapt to changing circumstances. A variety of factors can affect military adoption of new technologies,50 and adoption rates can vary considerably depending on the technology, state, and military community. Across a range of contemporary technologies militaries lag the private sector. For example, modern-day militaries are behind the private sector in adopting information technology, human performance optimizing technologies, and personnel best practices. With an increasing amount of technological innovation occurring outside of the defense sector, this lag is likely to continue.51 Yet, the key risk factor for military AI systems is not the timing of when militaries begin the process of adoption, but the taking of shortcuts in safety to accelerate fielding new AI capabilities. Adopting technology is a multi-stage process, involving research and development, experimentation, prototyping, technology maturation, production, testing, and fielding. It is possible for militaries to move slowly in one stage and quickly (or via shortcuts) in others. While there are many areas in which the U.S. military’s adoption of AI, autonomy, robotics, and uninhabited vehicles is moving slowly due to a variety of bureaucratic obstacles, it is also possible that the United States could rush parts of the adoption process and end up with immature technology in production or even in the field. This mixed dynamic, of moving slowly in some aspects of technology development and taking shortcuts in others, has been present in other defense programs. The F-35 fighter jet went into production before the first test flight, a decision that the Defense Department’s top acquisition official, Frank Kendall, later characterized as “acquisition malpractice.”52 Yet, the whole acquisition program took 25 years from its initial conception to its first operational deployment.53 The F-35 is still not in full rate production, 28 years after it was initially conceived of.54 The F-35 program moved too quickly in some areas, introducing unnecessary risk, even while it was overall encumbered by the laborious pace typical of major defense acquisition programs. Militaries’ sluggish bureaucracy is, therefore, no defense against shoddy testing and premature fielding.