The spread of military AI is inevitable – setting standards for reliability is key to avoiding disaster.
Horowitz, 2018 – Professor of Political Science at UPenn [Michael, September “The Algorithms of August: The AI arms race won't be like previous competitions, and both the United States and China could be left in the dust,” https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/09/12/will-the-united-states-lose-the-artificial-intelligence-arms-race/ 6/18/22 MD]
GIVEN AI'S MANY POTENTIAL MILITARY USES, policymakers need to rethink the idea of an AI arms race and what it will mean for international . The fundamental dilemma facing most attempts at arms control is that the more useful a technology is at providing with an edge, the harder it is to effectively regulate. There is, after all, no arms control agreement that meaningfully restricts countries from developing tanks, submarines, or fighter jets. Effective agreements tend to restrict the use of less important weapons that don't decide --such as landmines and blinding lasers--or ones that have rarely been used, such as nuclear weapons. suggests that those applications of AI with the greatest relevance for fighting and winning wars will also be the hardest to regulate, since states will have an interest in investing in them. Countries with advanced AI companies will be able to leverage those businesses to provide them with some military capabilities, either through adapting commercial technology or by offering financial incentives for talented researchers to focus on defense applications of AI. In these areas, the competition will be fierce because many actors could develop similar algorithms. Some AI applications, such as operational planning for a complex battlefield or algorithms designed to coordinate swarms of planes or boats trying to attack an enemy target, may appeal exclusively to militaries (though even swarms have nonmilitary applications, including firefighting). But even though there are clear military applications, AI cannot be compared to nuclear or or even military mainstays such as tanks. AI is not itself a weapon. Just as there was not an arms control regime for combustion engines or electricity, it's hard to imagine an effective regime for containing the coming AI arms race. Mitigating the military risks involved should therefore focus on specific potential uses of AI, rather than the broad technology category. For example, the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, which focuses on weapons systems with the potential to cause excessive or indiscriminate injury, is convening discussions in Geneva with countries around the world about lethal autonomous weapons systems. It is critical, however, not to let the specter of killer robots obscure the broader ways AI could reshape militaries, just as the general purpose technologies of previous centuries did. Rapid technological advances that outpace the ability of governments to administer them, fear of falling behind other countries, and uncertainty about the range of what is possible magnify the challenge of effectively regulating AI. Moreover, given the potential for economic investments in AI to spill over into potential military applications, many countries beyond the United States, China, and Russia may balk at regulatory approaches that limit their ability to develop more effective defense forces. Still, governments can create norms and practices surrounding the use of AI both inside and outside of militaries. Setting standards for AI reliability is one possibility, just like international standard setting in other arenas, such as Wi-Fi. Focusing on AI safety is a promising avenue to help ensure that, whatever forms of AI a defense team chooses to adopt, those applications work as intended. Predicting how AI will impact the future of warfare is difficult; it means assessing technologies that are still mostly immature. Much could change in just a few years. If a decade from now current predictions about the military uses of AI turn out to have been more fiction than fact, one reason might be because militaries failed to design algorithms that were robust and secure enough to withstand efforts by sophisticated adversaries to deceive and distort them.