Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Aff is not based on Realist assumptions – our call for global norms and limits on arms reject realist assumptions. We rely on Utility Theory to explain the status quo

Sosanya, 2022 - AI researcher and a policy analyst at the Day One Project [Andrew, Jan 3, Peace Review A Journal of Social Justice “Autonomous Weapons Are Here to Stay” https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/10402659.2021.1998856 TM]

To understand why states ban weapons, we must first examine the dynamics of conflict and cooperation. The international system composed of states is commonly viewed through two lenses: realist and constructivist. From a realist stance, states exist in an anarchic world, and their actions are solely driven by security concerns, power, and material interests. While cooperation may occur through international institutions such as the United Nations (UN), realists believe that arms control is merely a tool of statecraft that solely reflects the distribution of power among states. To a realist, states agree to ban weapons only if they have little to no military utility. On the other hand, constructivists view the world as a product of social interactions within a web of different actors that gradually builds up preferential outcomes and behaviors. A central tenet of constructivism is the idea of norms that bind standards of behaviors influencing what these actors believe they “ought” to do, rather than making the most self-serving choice. Thus, states are conditioned to take a collaborative, humanitarian approach to arms control and ban weapons that their leaders and citizens believe to be inhumane, in which there exists a stigma or moral abhorrence typically associated with the use of the weapon itself. While both constructivism and realism have their merits in explaining the dynamics of the world, they cannot individually capture why weapons get banned. Realism cannot adequately explain why states ban weapons at all, nor can constructivism explain why states still develop and deploy certain weapons that are considered to be inhumane, even amongst those who use them. To predict what path of prohibition states will take with autonomous weapons, I introduce a framework that strikes the optimal balance between the two schools of thought: utility theory. Utility theory posits that states cannot cooperate to ban a class of weapons, inhumane or not, if they are considered by states to be decisive, meaning that they are crucial to winning a war. If those weapons are seen as indecisive and inhumane, however, states can cooperate on prohibition because the weapons’ stigma outweighs their usefulness. Utility theory predicts that autonomous weapons will not be banned because key stakeholders—state decision makers—are optimistic about their tactical and strategic benefits. These stakeholders consist of military leaders, political leaders, and others in the defense industry, and they have invested heavily in the development of autonomous weapons and auxiliary technologies, showing no sign of stopping anytime soon. With autonomous weapons, states can project more power with more efficiency and speed than states without them.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.