Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Autonomous weapons reinforce the idea of perfection through technology that will elevate us above our enemies. This elevation is always accompanied by Imperial violence.

Kalpozos, 2020 - Prof of Law at Harvard [Ioannis 3-16-2020, , Leiden Journal of International Law, “Double elevation: Autonomous weapons and the search for an irreducible law of war", https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3545332 accessed on 6-18-2022]

3. Double elevation and the distancing of judgement Technology is not neutral.68 Assuming the neutrality of technology – and attaching to it the assumed neutrality of law – precludes any critical understanding of either. Technology, its development and use, reflects both theoretical and practical commitments: it ‘is covert philosophy’.69 It exists in a relationship of co-production with culture, politics, and law.70 As Paul Edwards put it in a seminal study of Cold War weapons technology, ‘we can make sense of the history of computers as tools only when we simultaneously grasp their roles as metaphors in … the period’s … science, politics and culture’.71 In this section, I argue that the promise of technological progress and automation in war, as in general, is a promise of civilization, a promise of improvement. It entails a double elevation: above one’s enemy and above one’s self. At the centre of it there is a paradoxical assumption, namely that the non-human can be more humane than the human. The elevation above one’s enemy combines military distance with a perception of civilizational and moral superiority. The elevation above oneself aims at creating a distance from human features perceived as weak or unreliable. Both full autonomy and merged heteronomy require the increasing mechanization of human judgement. What we have learned to understand as the civilization of war-fighting rests on and pursues its mechanization. 3.1. Rising above one’s enemy Technological distancing aims at developing asymmetry and invulnerability and elevating oneself above one’s enemy in both strictly speaking military and broader civilizational terms. The latter type of elevation allows not simply a geographical distance but also a moral distance with significant consequences for the role of law and judgement in killing. Military technology is central to early imperialist expansion72 and its concomitant civilizational pretension, culminating in the steep military and moral asymmetry achieved in nineteenth century colonial warfare. Churchill’s description in the context of the Boer war of the British infantry ‘steadily and solidly’ firing against the Sudanese Dervishes in ‘the most signal triumph ever gained by the arms of science over barbarians’, while ‘the mere physical act became tedious’,73 is illustrative. Technology allows military superiority, guaranteeing the physical safety and invulnerability of one’s forces; the asymmetry achieved reflects an already assumed civilizational distance which allows a moral dissociation from the act of killing, expressed in the ennui of physical exertion; the civilization of the technologically advanced party is enforced.74 The role of military technology in the elevation above one’s enemy is most closely associated with the growth of air power and the aspirations of invulnerability associated with it. Air power, especially in situations of colonial asymmetry, constituted a relationship of vertical distance, allowing the surveillance and policing of one’s inferior enemy, both at initial conquest and through the protracted practice of colonial administration and pacification.75 That colonial relationship achieved new technological heights in the context of the Cold War. Towards the end of the 1960s, the Vietnam impasse pushed for the assertion of asymmetry through the development of an automated battlefield to improve targeting capacity and protect American soldiers. Operation Igloo White attempted the surveillance of the Ho Chi Minh Trail in Laos through the use of camouflaged sensors designed to detect different types of human activity, including body heat, vehicle noise or the smell of human urine,76 or sweat.77 When picked up, such activities appeared on the screens in the headquarters’ terminals in Thailand and fed into the targeting system of military aircraft. A ‘kill box’78 was constructed and targeted. The operation’s centralized, computerized, automated method of ‘interdiction’ relied on an active global defence and aspirations for the full automation of the battlefield. These are set out by General William Westmoreland, the Chief of Staff of the US Army at the time, in a tenor strongly evocative of our present debate: On the battlefield of the future, enemy forces will be located, tracked, and targeted almost instantaneously through the use of data links, computer assisted intelligence evaluation, and automated fire control. … I see battlefields on which we can destroy anything we locate through instant communications and the almost instantaneous application of highly lethal firepower. … [A]n improved communicative system … would permit commanders to be continually aware of the entire battlefield panorama down to squad and platoon level … I am confident the American people expect this country to take full advantage of its technology - to welcome and applaud the developments that will replace wherever possible the man with the machine … With cooperative effort, no more than 10 years should separate us from the automated battlefield.79 As it turns out, Operation Igloo White was a complete failure.80 And yet the technological ambition remained. In 1973 the New Scientist echoed General Westmoreland’s technological/military optimism. There was ‘at present, great interest in the development of remotely piloted vehicles (RPV’s) for missions such as reconnaissance, electronic warfare, ground attack and air-to-air combat’.81 Increasingly, to these purposes was added another: targeted assassination. The ambition of the precision of a self-sustaining intelligence/targeting loop in drone warfare illustrates the confluence of offensive and defensive imperatives in elevating oneself above one’s enemy. Markus Gunneflo has shown how the practice of and legal justification for targeted killings was developed in Israeli and US policy as a means of constitutional protection of the citizens to be distinguished from unlawful assassination.82 In such ‘active defence’, especially when exercised globally, we see the merging of the offensive distance of air power, seeking to impose a vertical relationship of war, and the defensive distance of integrated human/machine surveillance systems. This vision is reflected in the prioritization in the 1990s of drone research.83 Drones, both the surveillance and the targeting kind, have been seen as symbolizing a ‘change of paradigm’ in the conduct of war.84 They, however, follow the trajectory discussed – that of achieving an elevation above one’s enemy, associated with geographical distancing and the moral/civilizational distance associated with governing through war from above.85 The present ambition, of both escalated weapon emancipation and human/machine merging, follows that same path. However autonomous, further distancing remains the goal.86 This is not a paradigm change.87 However, to the extent that there is a rapid acceleration of technological development we could, perhaps, refer to an ‘avalanche’: ‘when conditions are ripe, individual events, even small ones, can trigger a massive, downward rush’.88 This metaphor may serve to describe a well-established trajectory combined with the feeling that things may be spiralling out of control. From colonial asymmetry to the post-Cold War fighting of ‘terror’, the elevation above one’s enemy through weapons technology guarantees physical and moral distance; it also denotes, and imposes, the pretention of a higher civilization. As we will see, the promise of precision, professionalization, optimization of decision making – with humans involved, but assisted by technology – underlines another kind of elevation: one that supposedly saves humans from themselves.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.