Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Affirmative relies on dehumanizing assumptions – the argument that laws can be established to prevent AI is based on the same assumption that LAWs can perfect human warfare. Both rely on enlightened rationalist ideas of progress, ignoring how this perfection numbs us to dehumanizing violence.

Kalpozos, 2020 - Prof of Law at Harvard [Ioannis 3-16-2020, , Leiden Journal of International Law, “Double elevation: Autonomous weapons and the search for an irreducible law of war", https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3545332 accessed on 6-18-2022]

This article intervenes in a rather crowded debate. Why is there such a flurry of current interest in autonomous weapons and their legal regulation? A visceral reaction to the idea of mechanized killing, combined with the perception of the acceleration of artificial intelligence research,12 may be a sufficient answer. The anticipation of incoming practical problems to-be-solved, questions posed by powerful interested parties, may also be an incentive for lawyers to place their analyses in the marketplace of ideas. But I believe there is more to it. The present is the time to imagine the future, especially when one is both propelled by and unmoored from the past. The mix of artificial intelligence, war, and law draws some of its headiness from a specific historical moment – a culmination of and a departure from enlightenment rationalism; the apex of progress and the moment when we fear it will get out of hand. ‘The end of the end of history’13 marks a daunting beginning. The law of war carries this tension, with respect to both the articulation of rules and their enforcement. The legal institution of war rests on the survival of a soldier’s individual sense of humanity at the time when his life is laid out for the collective. So does individual (criminal) liability: without that assumption – without that fiction – it makes no sense. I argue that the increasing mechanization of warfare pursues the creation of distance from our enemies and from ourselves and reduces the knowledge and intelligence of the law and its application through individual judgement. I further argue that legal research on new weapons technology should focus less on questions of compatibility between given legal rules and the algorithmic and kinetic features of new weapons, as most current scholarship does, and more on an understanding of law as non-reducible to algorithmic engineering. I start, in Section 2, by reviewing the state of the art-in-the-making. Rather than providing an exhaustive taxonomy I aim to highlight the teleological nature of artificial intelligence research and the industry’s investment in the dialectic of increasing machine autonomy and human/machine merging, or ‘merged heteronomy’. I then see, in Section 3, this relationship between technology and war in some historical perspective, with a view to discerning functions relevant to law. I argue that the role of technology in war entails a double elevation: above one’s enemy and above oneself. The elevation above one’s enemy, discussed in Section 3.1, serves a both offensive and defensive impetus and aspires to both spatial and moral/civilizational distance. The elevation above oneself, discussed in Section 3.2, is for self-perfection. It is often associated with a certain understanding of Cartesian dualism and a belief in rational improvement that may see humanity as the cause of inhumanity and de-humanization as our best chance for humanization. It seeks to mechanize judgement and therefore establish a distance from human failings. It is served by war as governance from a distance and by the increasing physical and cognitive merging of humans and machines. Both physically and, to some extent, in moral and civilizational terms, technology and automation promise such improvement through establishing a distance from the human – our human enemy and our human self. The establishment of this distance entails a decreasing role for human judgement and the weakening of responsibility for such judgement. I further argue, in Section 3.3, that law, or certain strands of mainstream jurisprudence, are complicit in such mechanization, to the extent that law is treated as logic even conceivably reducible to algorithm. And that the reaction against this process of distancing and de-humanization, to the extent that it idealizes the proscriptive or regulatory role of law, is bound to disappoint.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.