The Plan will fail - lack of JAIC authority makes budgeting impossible
Tarraf, Shelton, Parker 2019 - Senior Information Scientist, Senior Engineer, and physical Scientist at the RAND Corporation [ Danielle C., William, Edward, et al RAND Cooperation, “The Department of Defense Posture for Artificial Intelligence”, file:///Users/MiraAgarwal/Downloads/RAND_RR4229%20(2).pdf, Acc 6/18/22, M.A.]
The JAIC lacks the authorities to carry out its present role. At its core, the JAIC’s overarching mission can be distilled to this: Scale AI and its impact across DoD. This mission and its present scope—as defined by the summary of the DoD AI strategy and the memo establishing the JAIC—are extensive, while the JAIC’s current authorities are limited. In particular, the JAIC is expected to synchronize DoD AI activities and coordinate AI initiatives totaling more than $15 million annually. It is unclear whether the JAIC has any mechanisms for enforcing these directives, because it does not have the authorities to direct investments or to halt programs or activities that are deemed to be misaligned with DoD’s strategy (a fact we learned through multiple DoD interviews). In short, the JAIC does not have directive or budget authorities, and that critically limits its ability to synchronize and coordinate DoD-wide AI activities to enact change. Currently, it can catalogue these activities, but it is unclear how doing so would help scale AI across DoD. Of course, that assumes that what constitutes an AI activity is known. However, it is not currently clear how the determination of what constitutes an AI initiative or activity is made, by whom, and whether that determination is consistent across DoD.8
JAIC fails – lack of long term funding certainty undermines industry support
Tarraf, Shelton, Parker 2019 - Senior Information Scientist, Senior Engineer, and physical Scientist at the RAND Corporation [ Danielle C., William, Edward, et al RAND Cooperation, “The Department of Defense Posture for Artificial Intelligence”, , Acc 6/18/22, M.A.]
The lack of longer-term budget commitments might hinder the JAIC’s success. This observation is not just about the amount of funding for the JAIC—for which we have no basis to judge at present— but also the horizon, certainty (or lack thereof), and general trends of funding commitments. Our insights gleaned from industry indicate that a sizable, long-term funding commitment, generally ramping up to accompany the five-year strategic road map, is critical to ensuring success in organizational transformations to enable scaling of AI (see section “Industry: Organization” in Appendix C). Based on our interactions with the JAIC, we were unable to determine whether the JAIC is able to submit budget requests through the programming, planning, budgeting and execution (PPBE) system as an independent entity, allowing it to request funds for the Future Years Defense Plan (FYDP) and also allowing high-level leadership to demonstrate support for the JAIC’s mission by prioritizing these budget requests.