Effective AI requires enormous amounts of data inputs, which are less available and more protected in the military sphere.
Goldfarb and Lindsay, 2022 – Chair in AI and health care at the Univ of Toronto, Prof of Cybersecurity at the Georgia Tech [Avi, Jon, 2/25/22, https://doi.org/10.1162/isec_a_00425, “Prediction and Judgement: Why Artificial Intelligence Increases the Importance of Humans in War” 6/18/22, LND]
Michael Horowitz describes AI as “the ultimate enabler” for automating decision-making tasks in everything from public administration and commercial business to strategic intelligence and military combat. In 2018, the Department of Defense observed that “AI is poised to transform every industry, and is expected to impact every corner of the Department, spanning operations, training, sustainment, force protection, recruiting, healthcare, and many others.” We would be surprised, however, if AI transformed all these activities to the same degree for all actors who use it. One of the key insights from the literature on the economics of technology is that the complements to a new technology determine its impact. AI, from this perspective, is not a simple substitute for human decision-making. Rapid advances in machine learning have improved statistical prediction, but prediction is only one aspect of decision-making. Two other important elements of decision-making—data and judgment—represent the complements to prediction. Just as cheaper bread expands the market for butter, advances in AI that reduce the costs of prediction are making its complements more valuable. AI prediction models require data, and accurate prediction requires more and better data. Quality data provide plentiful and relevant information without systemic bias. Data-driven machine prediction can efficiently fill in information needed to optimize a given utility function, but the specification of the utility function ultimately relies on human judgment about what exactly should be maximized or minimized. Judgment determines what kinds of patterns and outcomes are meaningful and what is at stake, for whom, and in which contexts. Clear judgments are well specified in advance and agreed upon by relevant stakeholders. When quality data are available and an organization can articulate clear judgments, then AI can improve decision-making. We argue that if AI makes prediction cheaper for military organizations, then data and judgment will become both more valuable and more contested. This argument has two important strategic implications. First, the conditions that have made AI successful in the commercial world—quality data and clear judgment—may not be present, or present to the same degree, for all military tasks. In military terms, judgment encompasses command intentions, rules of engagement, administrative management, and moral leadership. These functions cannot be automated with narrow AI technology. Increasing reliance on AI, therefore, will make human beings even more vital for military power, not less. Second, the importance of data and judgment creates incentives for strategic competitors to improve, protect, and interfere with information systems and command institutions. As a result, conflicts over information will become more salient, and organizational coordination will become more complex. In contrast with assumptions about rapid robot wars and decisive shifts in military advantage, we expect AI-enabled conflict to be characterized by environmental uncertainty, organizational friction, and political controversy. The contestation of AI complements, therefore, is likely to unfold differently than the imagined wars of AI substitutes.