Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Congress opposes offensive cyber operations because they could make us a party to a war against Russia.

Michael N. Schmitt | Jun 6, 2022 UKRAINE SYMPOSIUM – U.S. OFFENSIVE CYBER OPERATIONS IN SUPPORT OF UKRAINE https://lieber.westpoint.edu/us-offensive-cyber-operations-support-ukraine/

The challenge for our purposes is that, as is clear from the JP 3-12 extract above, the term “offensive cyberspace operations” can refer to those below the level of a use of force, like one that merely disrupts Russian command and control or logistics. Indeed, a cyber operation might be “offensive” for U.S. doctrinal purposes but not “armed force” for IHL purposes. Thus, without knowing more about the operations to which General Nakasone was referring, and in light of the uncertainty as to the threshold at which cyber operations initiate an IAC, no definitive conclusion regarding whether the U.S. operations standing alone initiated an armed conflict between the United States and Russia is possible (assuming one is not already underway as a matter of law, see ). Second, U.S. offensive cyber operations could make the United States a party to the IAC between Russia and Ukraine based on so-called “co-belligerency,” a subject I addressed in a prior in this series. That post was prompted by reports that the United States shared intelligence that enabled Ukrainian forces to engage in lethal and destructive targeting, including against Russian generals and the cruiser Moskva.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.