Won’t pass – Dems will insist on including immigration provisions in the final reconciliation which Republicans won’t accept.
JEFFREY MERVIS JUN 22 2022 https://www.science.org/content/article/democrats-lobby-high-tech-immigration-reforms-innovation-bill-congress
The COMPETES Act passed the House with the support of only one Republican lawmaker. And there are no such immigration provisions in the Senate version, which won significant Republican support. That means Lofgren and her Democratic colleagues must convince enough Senate Republicans that these narrowly focused changes to current immigration policy belong in the final bill because they are essential to sustaining U.S. innovation. A hearing last week by a Senate judiciary subcommittee on immigration made public those deep partisan divisions. The 14 June hearing focused on the plight of so-called Dreamers—undocumented immigrants living in the United States since they were children who have been given a temporary reprieve from deportation through the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. But that program, created in 2012, faces legal challenges that could soon lead to its termination. Some DACA recipients are early-career scientists, like Dalia Larios, a resident in radiation oncology at Harvard Medical School who came to the United States from Mexico at the age of 10. Larios was the first DACA recipient to enter Harvard Medical School, and she testified about how students like her are eager to remain and apply their talents to bolster U.S. economic growth. The panel’s Republicans readily acknowledged the contributions of immigrant scientists and engineers to U.S. innovation. But some suggested it was premature to make new rules for foreign-born researchers before deciding how to deal with other groups, such as the Dreamers. “Between DACA and STEM entrepreneurs, what should be Congress’s priority?” Senator John Cornyn (R–TX), a key backer of the Senate innovation bill, asked Larios, who declined to choose. Speaking to ScienceInsider after the hearing, Cornyn said he’s worried that adding the House immigration provisions to the final product would put the entire bill in jeopardy. “Immigration is not the primary purpose of [the Senate innovation bill],” Cornyn said. “And based on my experience here, I think that the more it deals with immigration, the harder it will be to get it passed.” Other Republican senators believe border security must come first, and they don’t trust U.S. universities hosting foreign-born scientists to safeguard national security. If anything, said Senator Marsha Blackburn (R–TN), the new visa category and other provisions will make it easier for enemies of the United States to pilfer emerging technologies. Bernard Burrola, a senior officer at the 230-member Association of Public and Land-grant Universities, which backs a pathway to citizenship for DACA recipients and Lofgren’s provisions, rejected Blackburn’s premise. “We take this topic incredibly seriously,” he told Blackburn when she asked whether international academic collaborations pose a threat to national security. “And we work closely with the FBI to identify, understand, and ameliorate any risks.” Senator Alex Padilla (D–CA), who chaired last week’s hearing, urged his Republican colleagues to embrace the immigration provisions in the House bill. “I hope we made it abundantly clear today that they are in the national interest, not just from an economic standpoint but also from the standpoint of national security,” Padilla said after the hearing. “Tapping the best talent from around the world has given us our competitive edge, and that needs to continue.” But Padilla also acknowledged that Democrats are a long way from closing a deal. “I do think immigration reform is central to the [final innovation] bill,” he told ScienceInsider. “But I guess we have more work to do to convince [Republicans] of that.”