It triggers an arms race---nuclear war
Rebecca Slayton, 2017, (Rebecca; 2/1/2017; PhD in chemical biology from Harvard University, Masters in chemistry and chemical biology from Harvard University, Bachelor’s in chemistry from Westmont College, author of Arguments that Count: Physics, Computing, and Missile Defense, winner of the Computer History Museum Prize, author of Shadowing Cybersecurity, winner of a 5-year National Science Foundation CAREER award, project lead on research funded by the Department of Homeland Security Center of Excellence’s Critical Infrastructure Resilience Institute; “What is the Cyber Offense-Defense Balance?” What Is the Cyber Offense-Defense Balance?” https://cornell.app.box.com/s/58xm5d4xwbdjq549vx5xnwc3qu1dqybk; Date Accessed: 7/10/2017/ceng
“In cyberspace, the offense has the upper hand.” 1 These words, written in 2010 by Deputy Secretary of Defense William Lynn, reflect conventional wisdom among military officers, policymakers, and scholars. 2 A minority of scholars disagree. 3 Nonetheless, the prevalent belief that cyberspace favors the offense has major consequences for international security. According to offense-defense theory, state perceptions that technology favors the offense increase fears of attack encourage arms races, and through interactions between fears and capabilities, increase the likelihood and consequences of war. 4 Overconfidence in the advantages of offense can create a “cult of the offensive” with potentially tragic results. 5 Many of these dynamics appear to be at work with cyber conflict. Military leaders perceive cyberspace as favoring the offense and are seeking more discretion to conduct offensive cyber operations. 6 Cyberattack features prominently in the U.S. intelligence community’s list of global threats. 7 In 2012 Defense Secretary Leon Panetta warned of a potential “cyber-Pearl Harbor.” 8 Fears of being hacked, optimism about hacking others, or both have spurred massive investments in military cyber operations around the world, suggesting a cyber arms race. 9 Because cyber operations can blur lines between espionage (or “cyber exploitation”) and use of force (or “cyberattack”), they create a “cybersecurity dilemma,” wherein network intrusions undertaken for defensive purposes are easily misunderstood as preparation for an attack, creating the risk of escalation and use of force. 10