Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Kinetic warfare

David Gompert and Martin Libicki, 2015, (David and Martin; 7/22/2015; researcher @ RAND and Principal Deputy Director of National Intelligence from 2009 to 2010, PhD in economics from the University of California Berkeley and Master’s in city and regional planning from the University of California Berkeley; “Waging Cyber War the American Way,” http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00396338.2015.1068551; Date Accessed: 7/10/2017/ceng

US ambivalence toward cyber war is both strategic and normative, the implication being that what is bad for the United States is also bad for the world. Washington insists that any cyber operations it might conduct would be ‘in a manner consistent with US and international law’.5 Perceiving cyber war as war implies the applicability of the laws of war, specifically the principles of non-aggression, non-intervention, proportionality, discrimination and respect for neutrality.6 Compliance with all these norms could be challenging when initiating and conducting offensive cyber war. Case in point: the United States and Israel are said to have created and inserted the Stuxnet worm to interfere with the control of centrifuges used by Iran to enrich uranium. However justified by the imperative of preventing Iran from building nuclear weapons, it is fair to ask if this act of cyber war was lawful, especially in light of the unintended collateral effects it reportedly had. More broadly, harming non-combatants and civilian life, which can occur when infecting non-military computer systems, raises especially vexing issues, at least for the United States – thus its defensive posture. There are several obvious reasons for US wariness about offensive cyber war. Firstly, US military, intelligence, economic, governmental and societal functions are highly dependent on computer systems, and vulnerable to their disruption and degradation. Put starkly, having led and benefited enormously from the ‘digital revolution’, the United States regards cyber war as counter-revolutionary. Moreover, once begun, the course a cyber war might take would be hard to predict, control or contain. It could trigger kinetic hostilities, visit indiscriminate harm on non-combatants, escalate far beyond what the belligerents intended, and cause grave economic damage.7 Finally, US superiority in conventional military capabilities limits the need for cyber war, whereas enemies could use cyber war as an asymmetric answer to such superiority. In other words, cyber war could level the battlefield to the US disadvantage.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.