1 Mosaicism & Autonomy
Krizia Rivera 2020 Genetic Engineering, Lack of Regulation in the United States of America and its Potentially Problematic Applications https://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2092&context=student_scholarship
The ethical concerns would probably be best understood under bioethical standards. Central to the practice of medicine and biological sciences are “The Four Principles of Bioethics, 75 ” also known as the four-principles approach. 76 This approach was developed by two American philosophers, Tom Beauchamp77 and James Childress. 78 This approach has long held that at the root of biomedical ethics are the following four principles: respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. These principles will lay the fundamental groundwork for each foreseeable potential human rights violation I state below. Personal autonomy means the right to make his or her own choice79. This principle will be violated if germline editing is allowed, mainly because it affects future generations as discussed above, given their obvious lack of consent as to inherited modified genes. The creation of a heritable modified genes has unpredictable implications on humankind and evolution80. In a 2018 commentary article authored by professors and research scholars noted there may be unintended consequences to editing out harmful mutations in humans: Here we simply emphasize to express that it may have effect modification of mutations in germ cell will ultimately eliminate that mutation in the next generation, which will deter the on-going human evolution. Mutations are an essential part of evolution, whose pros and cons cannot be judged instantly. The mutations, which seem deleterious today, may have inclusive fitness tomorrow. Mutations, which seem harmful today, may be the nature’s preparation for tomorrow. The somatic cell modifications in humans whereas provide answer to many ailments, the germ line changes until outcomes of such modifications are uncontrolled would continue to raise ethical concerns. Thus, the researchers need to be doubly cautious and some stringent regulations should be framed regarding the various aspects of germ line gene modifications and any potential conflict with nature for future outcome.81 Moreover, the elimination of a gene or modification of a gene could affect the genetic diversity of the human population82. The United Nations has defined genetic diversity as, “[t]he variation in the amount of genetic information within and among individuals of a population, a species, an assemblage, or a community.” 83 Genetic diversity is our inherited toolkit, and the more varied the genes are in our toolkit as a population, the higher our survivability will and continue to be. “Genetic diversity has a direct relation to the fitness and survivability of various species and populations; as genetic diversity decreases within a population, so does the fitness and survivability of that population.” 84 Notably, we do not understand the far-reaching potential of a gene, whether it is consider a harmful mutation today or not, it may serve a purpose tomorrow. Employing such a germline edit that would be inherited by future generations without their consent. The lack of medical consent of future generations is a contravention of human rights as it breaches their physical integrity, their ability to make choices as to their own bodies. Foreseeable issues as to consent have been posed by several scientists. Per legal standards and clinical ethics, it’s long been established that parents are the best and most appropriate decisionmakers over their children until they have reach adulthood. But this presumption is not perfect as individuals who have disagreed with the medical decisions of their parents is well-documented. For example, “wrongful life” suits85 or individuals who have disagreed with their parent’s surgical decisions about sexual assignment or craniofacial disorders.”86 There are also groups of people who resist the idea of having their medical status defined as a “disability,” and published cases of patients who are documented as stating they would not want to correct their medical condition if given the choice.87 The two principles, beneficence and non-maleficence, derives from the well-known Hippocratic Oath, “to help and do no harm. 88” This age-old oath was established in the 4th century BCE by Hippocrates, a physician-philosopher. As with any new scientific discovery, the true long-term effects of CRISPR cannot be realistically gasped. Currently, the known possible negative effects of genetic engineering are off-target mutagenesis 89,90 and mosaicism9192,93 . Applying a benefit-burden analysis, we must rely on alternative safer methods, such as, preimplantation genetic diagnosis, until we can reasonably and reliably predict the true effects of CRISPR. Lastly justice, is a concept concerning fairness and equality. The more pragmatic concern involves a lack of accessibility, where “therapies,” may be developed using this technology, but may only be accessible to the wealthy would add to the already great wedge between socioeconomic classes.