2 The gene drive
WESLEY W. CHEN June 30 2019 HUMAN GERMLINE GENE EDITING: ENGINEERING AN UNSTOPPABLE TRAIN https://mylaw2.usc.edu/why/students/orgs/ilj/assets/docs/28-2-Chen.pdf
One practical application of gene editing in eugenics is the idea of the gene drive.119 The gene drive is a genetic phenomenon whereby certain genes with “‘selfish’ genetic elements”—which provide hereditary advantages— increase the inheritance of the gene in subsequent generations within a population.120 The idea is that by using gene drives for advantageous characteristics, scientists can utilize a longitudinal system to address “major biological problems related to public and environmental health.” 121 In practice, a gene drive involves engineering specific genetic traits in a few individuals and propagating the traits throughout the local population through generations of reproduction.122 Due to difficulties surrounding engineering an effective gene drive system, gene drives have only been used in a handful of organisms, including yeast,123 fruitflies,124 and mosquitoes.125 With the evolution of CRISPR-Cas9 technology, however, development of gene drives are becoming increasingly viable. For example, historically it has been extremely difficult to create transgenes in mosquitoes that would be passed on to subsequent generations.126 But in November 2015, scientists reported that they had successfully engineered a gene drive in mosquitoes using CRISPR-Cas9, which resulted in inheritance of the mutant gene in 99% of all offspring.127 CRISPR-Cas9 technology has been subsequently used to engineer other mosquito gene drives to combat the spread of malaria.128 While the idea of using gene drives to eliminate malaria in wild mosquito populations seems promising, the application of gene drives in humans is not so straightforward. One of the gene drive’s greatest advantages is also one of its greatest weaknesses—its power to change an entire ecosystem.129 Theoretically, once a dominant gene drive has been introduced to favorably bias its inheritance, it will inevitably spread throughout the population unless an accessible off switch is programmed into the gene drive. In mosquitoes, an organism much simpler and more laboratory-tested than humans, such a dramatic genetic change would still have unforeseeable impacts on the ecosystem and the mosquito’s long-term survival in the wild. This illustrates both the causal uncertainties and the moral-conceptual “is this a benefit or risk” uncertainties in this field. Even the causal uncertainties aren’t purely empirical but have value components (as in proximate cause). In humans, these issues are further complicated in that it would be impossible to test the effects of gene drives on human adults in a laboratory setting. In a perfect scenario, a gene drive without any adverse or off-target effects could be introduced into the human population to battle disease and ubiquitously enhance the human race. Even in such cases, however, would it really be a good idea to drive the same genetic characteristic throughout society? One of nature’s best survival tools is genetic diversity.130 An advantageous trait one day may be a weakness another day when there are new diseases or different environments. The tug-and-pull between whether a genetic modification is helpful in the short-term or detrimental in the unforeseeable future highlights the blurred “line between diversity and disability.”