A ban on human germline genetic engineering is the only option
Darnovsky, Lowthorp and Hasson, 2018 Marcy Darnovsky is the executive director of the Centre for Genetics and Society (CGS). • Leah Lowthorp is a program manager at the Centre for Genetics and Society (CGS). • Katie Hasson directs the Genetic Justice program at the Centre for Genetics and Society (CGS). Reproductive gene editing imperils universal human rights ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED: February 15, 2018 https://www.openglobalrights.org/reproductive-gene-editing-imperils-universal-human-rights/
This prospect should make recent attempts to back-pedal on the widespread and longstanding international opposition to human germline modification particularly worrying to human rights advocates. For example, a 2017 by a committee of the US National Academies of Sciences and Medicine recommended that gene editing for human reproduction be permitted in certain circumstances, leaving open the possibility of expanding those circumstances in the future. But in the real world of commercial pressures and regulatory inadequacy, such limits would simply not hold. If the door to the use of human germline modification is cracked open, it will be impossible to limit its spread and applications. At this critical juncture, it’s important to remind ourselves why key human rights documents specifically prohibited these practices, long before they were technically feasible. The medical justifications for human germline modification fall short, and the temptation to “enhance” future generations is profoundly dangerous. Down that road, our scientific achievements would all too likely become not instruments of enlightenment and emancipation, but mechanisms for exacerbating inequality. And our desire to improve the human condition would lead us away from the realization of the human rights that we know are needed for individuals, societies, and humanity to thrive. The rapid pace of these developments creates an urgent need for the global community—perhaps gathering under UN auspices—to reaffirm existing agreements and clearly prohibit the dangerous and unethical use of reproductive gene-editing.