Germline editing puts multiple generations at risk and alters what it means to be human
Robert Sparrow 24 September 2015 Genetically engineering humans: a step too far? https://pharmaceutical-journal.com/article/opinion/genetically-engineering-humans-a-step-too-far
Some scientists have been quick to tout the potential of this new technology as a possible “cure” for some forms of infertility and to prevent various genetic diseases affecting future individuals. These hypothetical techniques would entail editing the genome of human embryos or of stem cells — a practice currently outlawed in the UK — that might then be coaxed into developing into sperm and eggs. What makes such hypothetical uses of genome editing especially controversial is that the genetic modification would — or at least could — affect the germline of the individuals who were brought into existence. Should something go wrong, multiple generations would be at risk. What germline modification could do that existing technologies cannot is produce embryos with particular genes associated with desirable traits. If scientists can find genes that are associated with above-species-typical traits — for example, higher intelligence, longevity, concentration or memory — CRISPR/Cas9 will allow them to insert these genes into embryos. In theory, at least, the CRISPR/Cas9 system would allow parents to insert genes for as many desirable traits as they liked into the genome of their child. Let us not be deluded, then, that the renewed debate about germline genetic engineering, prompted by CRISPR/Cas9, is about rescuing a small number of individuals from the burden of genetic disease. It is nothing less than a debate about what it will mean to be human in the future. Will our grandchildren — or perhaps even children — be born all equally subject to the vicissitudes — and the joys — of the genetic lottery? Or will they be made? Stronger, better perhaps — children of the wealthy more so than others — but are created by designers and so are vulnerable to obsolescence.