Germline editing violates autonomy and consent
(Aliya Jane, May 7th 2021, undergraduate student studying Physiological Science, OPINION: CRISPR Technology Violates Informed Consent, May Usher Era of Eugenics, Bruin Medical Review, https://bruinmedicalreview.com/2021/05/07/opinion-crispr-technology-violates-informed-consent-may-usher-era-of-eugenics/#:~:text=CRISPR%20violates%20informed%20consent.,result%20of%20the%20edited%20germline. Lbok)
Gene editing with CRISPR is used on two different cell types: somatic and germline. Germline cells are reproductive cells that eventually form embryos, sperm and oocytes. When targeting germline cells, effects can be felt for multiple generations due to their ability to pass on genetic information. Somatic cells refer to the rest of the body cells, excluding reproductive cells. Changes in somatic cells will not be passed down generationally. Using CRISPR to edit either type has ethical implications. Off-target mutations in both germline and somatic cells can result in negative health implications. Off-target mutations refer to nonspecific and unintended genetic modifications that can arise through the use of CRISPR. These could lead to very harmful effects on organisms, potentially even resulting in cell death. Germline editing also has a high risk factor because it can alter the genome of future generations. If there is some type of failure while editing the germline, undesirable mutations, side effects and other negative changes can also be inherited. This is especially risky because there is a lack of informed consent for offspring of future generations. Ethical Implications Informed consent is the process in which a health care provider educates a patient about the risks, benefits and alternatives of a given procedure or intervention. The patient, then, makes a voluntary decision about whether to undergo the procedure or intervention. CRISPR violates informed consent. When it is used to edit the germline, the affected unborn fetus cannot give consent to take part in the experimental procedure or manage any complications or undesirable mutations that might arise as a result of the edited germline. Therefore CRISPR violates the fundamental tenet of medicine of providing informed consent.