Jeopardizes fundamental human dignity
Roberto Andorno 2022 Human Dignity, Life Sciences Technologies and the Renewed Imperative to Preserve Human Freedom https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Roberto-Andorno/publication/360729946_Human_Dignity_Life_Sciences_Technologies_and_the_Renewed_Imperative_to_Preserve_Human_Freedom/links/628cecf0d4e5243d9b9624f7/Human-Dignity-Life-Sciences-Technologies-and-the-Renewed-Imperative-to-Preserve-Human-Freedom.pdf
A central argument made in this chapter is that the pervasive technology developments that we have been witnessing over the past few decades create new potential threats to human dignity, and therefore resorting to dignity is inescapable to address the new challenges. The need to protect basic human interests in this technological context may require the expansion of existing rights, and maybe even the creation of new rights in order to effectively preserve full respect for intrinsic human dignity. In consonance with this view, Italian legal philosopher Norberto Bobbio argues that the need for a new generation of human rights “arise[s] from the danger posed to life, liberty and security by the growth in technological progress.” 30 As examples of such new rights, he mentions those relating to new threats to privacy and to our genetic integrity. He adds, It does not take much imagination to realize that development of technology, the transformation of social and economic conditions, widening knowledge and the intensification of the means of communication will produce such changes in the organization of human life and social relations as to engender favorable conditions for the creation of new needs and therefore demands for freedoms and powers.31 However, human rights alone are not always sufficient to respond to the emerging challenges posed by technology. Sometimes, a direct recourse to the foundational principle of human dignity seems necessary to stress the utmost importance of the issues at stake. This explains why the instruments relating to bioethics adopted since the 1990s place a much stronger emphasis on the notion of dignity than traditional human rights instruments and even give a broader meaning to this concept. Precisely in those years, and partly as a result of the announcement of the Human Genome Project made in 1990, the notion of human dignity started to be used beyond its classical meaning (i.e., the intrinsic value of every human individual) to articulate disquiet about biotechnological developments that may impact on future generations and on humankind as a whole. Human germline engineering can be regarded as intrinsically problematic as it jeopardizes basic features of the human condition and the common understanding of what it means to be human. It is therefore the dignity of future generations that is at stake here.32