Its unethical – destruction of what it fundamentally means to be human and risks too many being relegated to second class status
Melanie Hess -2020 A Call for an International Governance Framework for Human Germline Gene Editing 95 Notre Dame Law Review 1369 https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4899&context=ndlr
The above passage primarily addresses the possibility that the use of germline editing for genetic enhancement would follow if germline editing were to become an acceptable procedure. In terms of acceptability, many distinguish between nontherapeutic genetic enhancement, or gene editing to engineer particular human traits like athleticism or intellect, and therapeutic gene editing, which addresses debilitating or life threatening genetic diseases.61 Marcy Darnovsky, head of the nonprofit Center for Genetics and Society, believes that “[u]nlike curing disease, genetic enhancement would be morally reprehensible.”62 The 1997 film Gattaca provides a cliche, but ´ apt, illustration of the potential societal problems of genetic enhancement and reflects society’s fears about eugenics and genetic interventions. In this dystopian not-too-distant future, parents have the option to conceive children through the genetic selection of the best traits of their parents, and the “in-valids”—individuals who were conceived without genetic intervention— occupy a second-class position in society.63 Despite laws against genetic discrimination, the Gattacan society found ways to relegate inferior employment and social positions to those individuals who were deemed genetically infer ior.64 Even the unrealized potential of such applications demonstrates the necessity of implementing proper regulation before germline editing gets off the ground so that it cannot be abused in these readily imaginable ways. These concerns are related to a commonly invoked principle of the “slippery slope,” in which concessions made to allow “acceptable” applications risk permitting unacceptable applications further down the road.65 There is also the ethical dilemma about the unnaturalness of germline editing and theologically based concerns that germline editing “amounts to playing God.”66 Although allegations of playing God are two a penny in debates about breakthrough technologies, with gene drives they do feel better-founded than usual. The ability to remove species by fiat—in effect, to get them to remove themselves—is, like the prospect of making new species from scratch, a power that goes beyond the past ambit of humankind.67 While the idea of causing extinction or making a species from scratch is referencing nonhuman applications of germline editing, the underlying principle—objecting to the tampering with species, including humankind— remains the same, if not possibly even more objectionable in substance. Even nonreligious persons have moral reservations related to this theory of “playing God” that takes the form of objection to the unnaturalness of the idea and how it constitutes a perceived assault on human dignity. A Pew Research study found that over twenty-five percent of nonreligious people opposed gene editing of a baby, even where doing so would improve that baby’s health, for the exact same reasons as did people who identified as religious—“because it would be meddling with nature and cross a line that should not be crossed.”68 Bioethicists have used the term the “yuck factor” to describe the intuitive aversion people feel when confronted with the idea of genetic engineering. “The Yuck Factor likely has its origins in Kantian and Christian philosophies of human dignity that permeate Western culture . . . [and] emphasize that human life has a higher moral place than the rest of the natural world.”69