Its discriminatory eugenics
WESLEY W. CHEN June 30 2019 HUMAN GERMLINE GENE EDITING: ENGINEERING AN UNSTOPPABLE TRAIN https://mylaw2.usc.edu/why/students/orgs/ilj/assets/docs/28-2-Chen.pdf
Eugenics is the idea of systematically applying genetic selection in humans.107 Negative eugenics teaches “breeding out” negative or unwanted characteristics (e.g. the Huntington’s Disease mutation); positive eugenics promotes desirable genetic traits (e.g. inheritable resistance to Malaria).108 While proponents for eugenics might argue that it would only be used as a positive tool for fixing some of society’s greatest problems (e.g. inheritable disorders), critics of eugenics would argue that the application of eugenics is not governed by such a bright-line rule. The controversy surrounding eugenics involves the ambiguity regarding what defines a negative or positive characteristic. There are some clear candidates for negative eugenics, such as a Tay-Sachs Disease—a fatal heritable disorder that results in severe mental retardation and death by the age of eight-years-old.109 But what about the genetic profile for Down Syndrome patients? Individuals with Down Syndrome experience mental retardation, but can live functional adult lives. Or what about the gene for lactose intolerance? When deciding what sort of genetic conditions deserve eugenic treatment, one must face the difficult, if not impossible task of making value judgments on each disorder.110 Depending on the subjective view for each person, what may be considered an unacceptable characteristic to one individual may be acceptable to another. Therefore, genetic conditions are less likely to fall neatly into rigid categories and more likely to rest in a spectrum ranging from clearly unacceptable disorders to controversial attributes. As one moves along the spectrum away from unanimously dreadful diseases, the room for disagreement increases. When such ambiguity exists, there is a greater risk that eugenics may be discriminatory. On one hand, eugenic champions might argue that it is unethical to deprive a mother an opportunity to use gene-editing technology to ensure a healthy child, and that society has a duty to produce healthier offspring.111 Negative eugenics could be limited to only clear and obvious cases (e.g., eliminating fatal genetic diseases); positive eugenics could enhance the human race through safe gene editing practices (e.g. increasing resistance to diseases). On the other hand, critics might argue that eugenics sits on a slippery slope and if we allow the possibility of “breeding out” negative characteristics, we will eventually find ourselves back in the 1940s alongside the atrocities of the Holocaust. Critics could also point out that even if society does not descend to such depths, the very concept of eugenics is discriminatory because it suggests that some lives are not worth living.112 If certain racial profiles become associated with diseases, eugenics risks stigmatizing such races.113 Furthermore, across and within different societies the economic availability of eugenic technology may greatly exacerbate inequality. For example, if the genes for high intelligence are identified and eugenic technology was only available at a high cost, already wealthy families would have a better opportunity to produce genetic “advantages” for their progeny. The ramifications of accelerating social, economic, and political stratification would be difficult to reverse.114 For such reasons, the risk of abuse has been deemed intolerable and eugenics has been mostly rejected in the past several decades.115 On the other hand, one can argue that there is a significant difference between preventing the birth of persons with certain genetic conditions and killing of persons bearing a specific trait. Especially considering the benefits that would come with eliminating unambiguously harmful genetic traits (e.g. Tay-Sachs disease116), the benefits of eugenics may outweigh the risks. Even if one was to accept that eugenics bears a substantial risk of propagating social inequality, is the risk enough to deny the benefits of eugenics to society? Benefits may come at a price. Regardless of where one stands on the eugenics debate, recent technological advances in gene editing have pumped new life into the eugenics debate. Whereas the historic versions of eugenics revolved around controlling reproductive partners—either by bringing persons together, keeping them apart, sterilization, or gamete selection (as with artificial insemination by donor)117—gene editing refines reproductive strategies by manipulating the very genetic material in any one individual.118