Unethical – intensifies genetic discrimination and social inequality – foundation of eugenics
Neal Baer 2020 Quals: Neal Baer is an award-winning showrunner, television writer/producer, physician, author, and a public health advocate and expert."Commentary: Code Dread?" Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 63, no. 1: 14-27. doi:10.1353/pbm.2020.0001. /nfs
Many scientists contend that the driving question CRISPR poses is whether it fulfills an unmet medical need and can be made clinically safe. Garland-Thomson, along with many of our other contributors, cautions that we must look further to “what the existence of CRISPR technology suggests about the limits of being human.” Garland-Thomson worries that GGE approaches a “new eugenics.” Using germline editing to enhance or improve future persons, she says, may lead to “morally unacceptable consequences, ranging from producing medical harm to abrogating consent, intensifying genetic discrimination, increasing social inequality, promoting conditional parental acceptance, turning people into products, fostering a commercial medical industrial complex, and encouraging rogue scientific and medical practice.”