Germline genetic engineering increases economic inequality
Scott J. Schweikart, Global Regulation of Germline Genome Editing: Ethical Considerations and Application of International Human Rights Law, 43 Loy. L.A. Int'l & Comp. L. Rev. 279 (2021). Available at: https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/ilr/vol43/iss3/6
The ethical principle of justice is derived from concepts of what is fair and equitable.45 Issues of justice are of concern for both somatic and germline genome editing. Consider the example of germline genome editing that would confer a benefit (such as a modification to help confer immunity):46 if such an “enhancement is available only to the upper classes, it can further widen the already existing gap between the more advantaged and less advantaged members of society and thus exacerbate injustices.”47 Ethically, the “benefits of heritable genome editing should not preferentially accrue only to the affluent individuals.”48 Indeed, there is a human rights aspect with regard to social justice, as “[t]he potential for discrimination against genetic groups increases dramatically as genetic testing and [germline manipulation] techniques become less expensive, more reliable, and more widely available.”49 Maha Munayyer explains that “[germline manipulation] provoke[s] discrimination based on genetic status while simultaneously providing the means to alter that status.”50 An additional concern is that the price of the technology is yet another way that inequality may spread, as “editing is likely to be expensive” and “[g]enetic disease, once a universal common denominator, could instead become an artifact of class, geographic location, and culture.”
Germline gene editing further entrenches economic inequality
CBC Radio · Posted: Mar 23, 2021 4:56 PM ET | Last Updated: March 23, 2021 https://www.cbc.ca/radio/thecurrent/the-current-for-march-23-2021-1.5960200/gene-editing-could-make-social-inequalities-worse-if-misused-warns-author-1.5960568
The rich would be buying better genes for their children, which would be a nightmare,' says Walter Isaacson. An American author and professor says he believes gene editing will be the most consequential ethical issue humans face in the coming decades — and that it could become problematic if we start using the technology to edit out our diversity. "These [technologies] are going to be totally transformative," he told The Current's Matt Galloway. "Where it crosses a line is when we start not just editing for diseases in a living patient, but we try to make enhancements in children and in reproductive cells." Last October, American biochemist Jennifer Doudna and French microbiologist Emmanuelle Charpentier shared the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for developing the CRISPR gene editing tool. The technology allows scientists to edit specific genes to remove errors that lead to disease. CRISPR has been hailed by the scientific community as a revolutionary tool, and is currently being used to try treating cancer and other diseases, such as sickle cell anemia. But some experts have also warned against using it to solve all our social problems, saying not enough is known about the risks it poses or its long-term effects. In 2018, Chinese scientist He Jiankui claimed to have made the world's first gene-edited babies. The move drew widespread criticism, and He was later imprisoned in China for his research. Deploying gene editing technology in such a way also worries Isaacson. If we start using gene editing to enhance our children, we could end up entrenching the inequalities that already exist in society, he said. "The rich would be buying better genes for their children, which would be a nightmare," Isaacson said. "If every individual gets to say, alright, [I want my kid to be] tall or short, or muscular or not muscular, or any type of traits a human could have, I think that would be bad to do." What we should be open to is "medically necessary" gene editing that could prevent people from inheriting ailments such as Huntington's or sickle cell disease, he said. However, deciding what is actually medically necessary is "a blurry line." Isaacson cited famous creative minds like Miles Davis, Van Gogh and Hemingway, who lived with a disease or mental illness. Despite that, they produced incredible works of art. "We don't want our kids to suffer from psychological ailments," Isaacson said. "On the other hand, if we wipe our species clean," it could lead us to become a "very placid species without diversity, and perhaps without edge." Some people have already pushed back against the idea of using gene editing to prevent certain conditions. In 2019, Canadian bioethicist Françoise Baylis denounced a Russian molecular biologist's plan to edit human embryos to prevent deafness. Baylis told As It Happens at the time that it was unclear if the science to do so was safe, and that modifying genes could have unintended consequences. She added that many people in the deaf community also don't see deafness as a disability, but rather as diversity. These kinds of moral and ethical debates call for international consensus, said Isaacson. And experts are already trying to come up with answers. Doudna herself has been calling for international regulations to control the use of CRISPR, while others have raised alarm bells about making genetically altered babies. Isaacson hopes his own insights can help as well. "I wrote this book so we can start thinking about those questions," he said.