Germline engineering locks in inequalities and freezes social mobility
Sam Pizzigati, 8-2-19 Sam Pizzigati spent two decades directing the publishing program at America’s largest union, the 2.8-million-member National Education Association, and before that edited the national publications of three other U.S. trade unions. “Can the Wealthy Hardwire Inequality into Our DNA?” https://inequality.org/great-divide/can-inequality-be-hardwired-into-our-dna/ Accessed 6/30/22 T.T
But what if wealthy parents had the ability to give their kids that athletic talent? What if our nation’s rich could use emerging 21st-century “gene-enhancement technology” to make their kids physically bigger, stronger, or faster? What if they could even use that same technology to make their kids smarter? Would they? The answer the college admissions scandal makes plain: Many of the richest among us will stop at nothing to perpetuate their privilege. Spend a fortune to make their kids genetically superior? Of course they would. Should we be aghast at this prospect? Of course we should. What used to be pure science fiction — the ability to edit our DNA — has now become science reality. A generation ago our hippest young programming hotshots were working in computer code. Now the high-tech hip are busy working to reprogram our genes. Worried senior scientists, historian Walter Isaacson, have begun talking “about the need for a moratorium on making edits that can be inherited.” They have plenty of reason to worry. In our deeply unequal world, grand private fortunes have much more of a capacity to shape how gene-enhancement technologies evolve than our scientists and ethicists. “Look at what parents are willing to do to get kids in college,” MIT neuroscientist Feng Zhang. “Some people will surely pay for genetic enhancement.” Should these super rich, asks Erik Sontheimer, a University of Massachusetts expert in molecular medicine, simply “be allowed to buy the best genes they can afford?” The genetic pioneer Zhang certainly doesn’t think so. Think of what that would do, he urges, “to our species.” Think about our societies, too. A “free market” for genetic enhancement, suggests historian Isaacson, might well encode our world’s current inequities on a permanent basis.