Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

An absolute and explicit ban is the only option – a possibility of violating the ban only means we should be more vigilant about the plan – any alternative to a ban is reckless

Hurlbut, J.B. (2020).the author of Experiments in Democracy: Human Embryo Research and the Politics of Bioethics (Columbia University Press, 2017) and co-editor of Perfecting Human Futures: Transhuman Visions and Technological Imaginations, (Dordrecht: Springer, 2016), as well as numerous articles and book chapters. He holds an A.B. from Stanford University and a Ph.D. in the History of Science from Harvard University. He was a postdoctoral fellow in the program on Science, Technology and Society at the Harvard Kennedy School. Imperatives of Governance: Human Genome Editing and the Problem of Progress. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 63(1), 177-194. doi:10.1353/pbm.2020.0013. /nfs

Why should this be? In what other domain of social life do we treat the violation of a prohibition as justification for abandoning that prohibition? We do not accept thievery and murder simply because there are always thieves and murderers in any society. Why should we respond to what David Baltimore in his rebuke to He at the Second International Summit described as “a failure of self-regulation by the scientific community” by doubling down on self-regulation by the scientific community (Statement of David Baltimore 2018)? Surely the judgment of an individual scientist, an advisory committee or even a whole professional community should not be privileged over a societal commitment to democratic governance simply because scientists feel constrained in their freedom to do what they want. Certainly it is challenging to achieve a democratic and cosmopolitan bioethics sufficient to govern a technology that “touches on the whole of humanity” (Hurlbut et al. 2018; Feinstein et al. 2019). Surely this means that we must redouble our efforts, not abandon them. Far from casting aside the aspiration to “broad societal consensus,” we should see with clear eyes what happens when scientists (and, thus, science) are left to decide for themselves the future of humanity. He’s hubristic project was an act of appropriation and has rightly been condemned as such. But so too is the move to substitute “broad scientific consensus on the responsible pursuit of human genome editing research and clinical applications” for “broad societal consensus” about our common future (Dzau, McNutt, and Bai 2018; Organizing Committee for the International Summit on Human Gene Editing 2015, emphasis added). One of the most startling features of the He debacle is the sense of urgency to race ahead that it has engendered in the upper echelons of international science. It is one thing for a young, ambitious and reckless scientist operating at “Shenzhen speed” to put the pedal to the floor (Kirksey 2020). When the leaders of international science declare an “urgent need to accelerate efforts,” hitting the gas in hot pursuit of runaway science that they themselves have branded as “rogue,” they are recklessly committing to a race of their own making (Dzau, McNutt and Bai 2018). Why not call a halt instead? In fact, some have done just that, calling for an explicit, international moratorium on creating genome-edited babies for a defined period of time (Lander et al 2019). It is extraordinary—and revealing—that this apparently unobjectionable proposal has itself become a focus of controversy. Opponents have argued that a de facto moratorium is already in place, but object to making it explicit by using the term itself (Begley 2019). The objection comes down to a preference for self-imposed scientific limitation, so that the scientists who impose limits at one moment are free to lift them in the next. David Baltimore has argued: The important point is to be flexible going forward. That’s what’s wrong with a moratorium. It’s that the idea gets fixed in people’s minds that we’re making firm statements about what we don’t want to do and for how long we don’t want to do it. With a science that’s moving forward as rapidly as this science is, you want to be able to adapt to new discoveries, new opportunities and new understandings. To make rules is probably not a good idea. (Saey 2019) Yet setting a rule that clearly prohibited HGGE—and threatening excommunication from international science for violating it—is precisely what would have restrained He and his boosters. Given this, why not make firm statements about “what we don’t want to do”? Yet, setting rules for what should or should not be done is not the remit of science alone. The question of whether to proceed, particularly on a matter that touches upon such fundamental dimensions of human life, belongs to all of us. There has not yet been a serious effort to invite inclusive public deliberation, to say nothing of anything resembling consensus. Why, therefore, should the default be to let research go forward? The reason is that what is at stake for the opponents of the moratorium proposal is not merely governance of genome editing, but scientific freedom as such—the sovereign authority of science to self-regulate and self-govern. As Baltimore explains: restricting gene editing “could hold back the science” (Saey 2019). In other words, science should race ahead, and ethics should lag behind—after all, “there’s nothing like actually moving ahead [with research] to teach us what the actual pitfalls are” (Saey 2019). But surely He Jiankui has already made it abundantly clear that the pitfall of blindly and recklessly moving ahead is that one moves ahead blindly and recklessly.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.