Experts support a ban – its narrowly tailored and still allows somatic engineering
ALICE PARK MARCH 13, 2019 2:22 PM EDT Experts Are Calling for a Ban on Gene Editing of Human Embryos. Here's Why They're Worried https://time.com/5550654/crispr-gene-editing-human-embryos-ban/
The ban applies only to a select set of studies that involve genetic changes to germline cells: studies that involve altering the genes in eggs, sperm or embryos that would then be transferred for pregnancy. The vast majority of genetic experts believe it’s too early for any technique, including CRISPR, to be used in this way, because the safety of the technology hasn’t been established yet. Although CRISPR, for example, gives scientists the most precise molecular scissors possible to snip human DNA exactly where disease-causing genes or mutations might reside — or to even replace portions of the genome with healthy DNA — studies in animals and cells in a lab dish show that sometimes the scissors splice where they aren’t supposed to. It’s also not clear what effect manipulating the human genome by removing or replacing fragments of DNA might have on people’s health — now, or for future generations. The moratorium calls for researchers and nations to suspend studies on human gene editing of eggs, sperm and embryos for about five years, and during that time, for countries agreeing to the ban to encourage societal discussion about how its citizens would like to see such work proceed. If a nation decided it was ready to begin conducting such studies again, it would share its plans with the international community, preferably two years ahead of time, so additional discussions could ensure that safety and ethical issues had been addressed. The moratorium does not apply to research on so-called somatic cells, or any other cell except the egg and sperm that are involved in reproduction. Somatic cells, such as blood and skin, are not passed on to the next generation, so any genetic changes made to a person’s own genome in these cells are not inherited. Promising studies involving gene editing to treat sickle cell, for example, won’t be affected by the ban. “Those clinical trials should not in any way be impeded by this,” says Collins. “The only focus on the moratorium is on embryos and germline manipulation with the intent to implant that embryo in the mother’s womb. It’s a very narrow prohibition. All the rest of the applications of gene editing should not only go forward, but should go forward vigorously and with great energy.”