Alternative methods to achieve germline ethical goals - and they are safer
Mills, P.F.R. (2020). Quals: Peter Mills is Professor of Anthropology at the University of Hawaii at Hilo. He holds his degrees from the University of California, Berkeley (Ph.D.), Washington State University, and the University of Vermont, and his fields of specialization are Oceania and New World Archaeology, complex societies, archaeometry, the archaeology of colonialism, indigenous archaeology, ethnohistory, exchange, and lithic technology. He is active with the Society for Hawaiian Archaeology, the Paniolo Preservation Society, and the North Hawaiʻi Education and Research Center’s Heritage Center. Genome Editing and Human Reproduction: The Therapeutic Fallacy and the "Most Unusual Case". Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 63(1), 126-140. doi:10.1353/pbm.2020.0010. /nfs
Part of the objection to GEHR is that for all the possible outcomes that GEHR may be expected to deliver, there are existing reproductive technologies for securing these outcomes. If this is the case, and these established procedures do not entail the same risks or uncertainties that GEHR does, then introducing GEHR could not be a proportionate means to achieve the desired outcome. What is this outcome? In most discussions of GEHR, this outcome is usually assumed to be the birth of a child with at least two preferred characteristics. The first is implicitly (although often only implicitly) the presence of a direct genetic link to both the prospective parents, which is achieved through the combining of their individual genomes, as happens in unassisted sexual reproduction. The second characteristic is the presence (or absence) of at least one other genetically conditioned feature that the combination of those genomes makes it unlikely (or likely) that any resulting child will inherit. Such a characteristic might be the absence of a serious disease that has been diagnosed in the prospective parents, like cystic fibrosis. Disease traits of this kind are usually assumed to be good candidates for the second characteristic. In such cases, however, GEHR is unlikely to be the only intervention available. There are reproductive technologies that involve the donation of sperm or eggs from third-party donors, thereby simply circumventing the genetic endowment from one parent. Since, however, these children would lack the first preferred characteristic (genetic relatedness), other approaches are also widely available in many (though not all) parts of the world. They involve genetic testing to select embryos for transfer (preimplantation genetic testing, or PGT) or to select pregnancies to carry to term (prenatal testing and termination of pregnancy, PNT/ToP).