Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No medical necessity for human germline gene editing. Oppenheimer has persuasively discredited the negs conception of risk for medical benefit – its at our peril we allow the legitimate possibility of human destruction.

Hurlbut, J.B. (2020).the author of Experiments in Democracy: Human Embryo Research and the Politics of Bioethics (Columbia University Press, 2017) and co-editor of Perfecting Human Futures: Transhuman Visions and Technological Imaginations, (Dordrecht: Springer, 2016), as well as numerous articles and book chapters. He holds an A.B. from Stanford University and a Ph.D. in the History of Science from Harvard University. He was a postdoctoral fellow in the program on Science, Technology and Society at the Harvard Kennedy School. Imperatives of Governance: Human Genome Editing and the Problem of Progress. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 63(1), 177-194. doi:10.1353/pbm.2020.0013. /nfs

The project of “consciously perfecting” human life begins with the misguided but well-meaning step of seeking to repair human beings that have been marked as lessor, inferior, or defective. For He’s would-be parents, the defect lay not in their future children’s DNA, but in a society that sorts, classifies, and seek to correct—or discard—those who do not measure up. No society is free of such defects. Yet acquiescing to them—editing children to compensate for the deficiencies of the societies into which they will be born—will amount to nothing less than affirming those deficiencies. Developing and deploying HGGE in the name of some unjustifiable notion of “medical necessity” amounts to setting this technology free to be used for genetic fixes for social problems—“cur[ing] prejudice”—of whatever sort the market will sustain. And the market that He imagined is vast. Liberating the technology in this way would deny the vast majority of the human community the freedom to ask whether we want it at all. If there is even a small possibility that developing heritable human genome editing could contribute to such a future (and as the He case makes clear, that possibility is far from remote), humanity has a duty to carefully contend with the question of how to guide and govern this technology. This entails asking not only what should be done, but how we should understand what is at stake: what questions need to be asked but are going unasked, how the terms of debate are being set, by whom, and with what consequences for which cultural, J. Benjamin Hurlbut 192 Perspectives in Biology and Medicine moral, and spiritual vocabularies can contribute to steering the ship. And yet the imperatives of governance that have guided debate thus far have taken us far off course. Unless we correct, the ways of thinking and speaking that this essay has examined will continue to drive the direction of technology—encouraging and justifying irresponsible science, sidelining serious ethical reflection, constraining democratic governance, and inhibiting deliberation that draws upon the wealth of tradition, experience and moral imagination. As we navigate into the uncharted waters of our technological future, we would do well to recall, with restraint and humility, that we are an imperfect species. The aspiration to heal the infirmities of our mortal lives, no matter how virtuous, is endlessly vulnerable to that all-too-human impulse to redeem ourselves though mastery of nature and self. It is but a short step from the desire to repair what is imperfect to the impulse to perfect. And one need not look long to see that the will to perfectibility is also a will to power— to render fragile and vulnerable human life an object of manipulation and control. Beneath a hunger for prestige and a belief in the virtue and righteousness of his project, He Jiankui was also driven by the thrill of it: the reckless speed, the heroic transgression, the wielding of an unprecedented and seemingly righteous power over the fragility of human life. So too were his aiders and abettors, members of a guild that wields ever-increasing powers over life. They encouraged He not in the name of healing the sick, but in the name of an imagined right—and righteousness—of radical scientific freedom to ordain the lives we shall have and the purposes for which we shall live. J. Robert Oppenheimer described this ethos more than half a century ago: “When you see something that is technically sweet, you go ahead and do it, and you argue about what to do about it only after you have had your technical success” (US Atomic Energy Commission 1954). The sweet successes of the nuclear age threatened to extinguish civilization itself. Biology’s emerging powers over the stuff of life, though far more subtle, are no less threatening to human integrity. It is at our peril that we the people cede the authority to guide and govern our common future to those who would mistake the sweetness of their own success for progress

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.