Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Other successful ways to deal with genetic diseases besides germline editing

Annie Sneed on April 15, 2019 Environmental Thinker Bill McKibben Sounds Warning on Technology https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/environmental-thinker-bill-mckibben-sounds-warning-on-technology/

I truthfully don't think that human genetic engineering offers us much in the way of benefit. If people are worried about genetic disease, we can already deal with that through preimplantation genetic diagnosis, which is used in fertility clinics around the world. It lets you make sure your child doesn't have a genetic disease, but it doesn't let you improve your child. So I don't think the benefits [of human germline genetic engineering] are very high, and the potential cost—in terms of meaning—is enormous.

The “medical necessity” argument is a farce – the cases are vanishingly rare

Hurlbut, J.B. (2020).the author of Experiments in Democracy: Human Embryo Research and the Politics of Bioethics (Columbia University Press, 2017) and co-editor of Perfecting Human Futures: Transhuman Visions and Technological Imaginations, (Dordrecht: Springer, 2016), as well as numerous articles and book chapters. He holds an A.B. from Stanford University and a Ph.D. in the History of Science from Harvard University. He was a postdoctoral fellow in the program on Science, Technology and Society at the Harvard Kennedy School. Imperatives of Governance: Human Genome Editing and the Problem of Progress. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 63(1), 177-194. . /nfs

And yet, for all the summits, advisory reports, and deliberations, there has been remarkably little direct engagement with what strikes me as the most fundamental question of governance: What is this technology for? This question has mostly been approached as a challenge to come up with scenarios in which embryo editing is “medically necessary” because it is the only means through which someone could have a healthy, genetically related child. Such cases are vanishingly rare. The Nuffield Council (2018) consulted with a number of genetic counselors, who reported never having encountered such a case in what amounted to hundreds of years of combined clinical experience. Yet regardless of how vanishingly rare candidate cases may be, searching for them amounts to a search for justification, not an inquiry into the technology’s purpose. The designer’s intentions do not determine what a technology is for — that is, the reasons it will be used and the uses it will be put to. To understand what a technology is for one must inquire into the ways it is likely to be incorporated into people’s lives and societies, looking to the ends it might be made to serve, and the senses of desire, obligation, or need that usher it in. Once again, the He case offers insight—and a powerful warning.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.