Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Restrictions fail – has to be a ban – risk is too much and collapses autonomy

Roberto Andorno 2022 Human Dignity, Life Sciences Technologies and the Renewed Imperative to Preserve Human Freedom https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Roberto-Andorno/publication/360729946_Human_Dignity_Life_Sciences_Technologies_and_the_Renewed_Imperative_to_Preserve_Human_Freedom/links/628cecf0d4e5243d9b9624f7/Human-Dignity-Life-Sciences-Technologies-and-the-Renewed-Imperative-to-Preserve-Human-Freedom.pdf

In his book The Future of Human Nature, Jürgen Habermas makes the case that the use of germline genetic engineering would give us an exorbitant power over our descendants and lead to a dramatic loss of liberty for future generations. In his view, preventing the manipulation of the genome of our descendants “is crucial for our capacity to see ourselves as the authors of our own life history, and to recognize us as autonomous persons.” 47 He claims that the principle of equality between generations crucially depends on the condition that each individual’s features are more to the result of chance than choice, of contingency rather than human design. Certainly, it can be argued, as is often done, that the germline alterations will only aim at preventing the transmission of genetically related diseases. The problem is that, even if this were the initial focus, the risk is too high that we will then gradually start to make genetic changes for the non-therapeutic design of children.48 Even the best-intentioned efforts to restrict the use of the technique to specified conditions would be unlikely to hold, for a number of reasons that cannot be discussed here.49 Besides that, it is well-known that the boundaries between “therapy” and “enhancement” are extremely difficult to define in real practice. Moreover, the expression “therapeutic purpose” is itself somehow misleading in this context. Germline gene editing does not aim to treat, cure, or prevent diseases in any existing patient. Instead, it aims to modify the genes of future children and generations through the intentional creation of embryos with altered genomes. Strictly speaking, the procedure is not a medical intervention but a way to satisfy parental desires for genetically related children or for children with specific genetic traits.50 In other words, we are not dealing with a therapeutic procedure but with a wish-fulfilling technology, which is something very different from an ethical and legal point of view. It must be noted that germline engineering is radically different from other technologies in the sense that it does not aim to change the tools that we use but the users themselves (that is, ourselves, or rather, our descendants), and in an irreversible manner. Some reports from scientific academies have argued that the procedure could become acceptable once the risks of side effects on the children can be reduced to a minimum.51 However, besides the fact that the concerns raised by the technique exceed by far the question of the purely medical side effects, can a risk that may unpredictably affect future people –either physically or psychologically – ever be regarded as “minimal”? Is the classic risk–benefit analysis really applicable to this radically new scenario? These questions are difficult to answer. What is clear is that humankind has rarely been confronted with such challenging issues concerning our self-understanding as free, non-engineered human beings, and the long-term effects of our technological choices.

Regulations cannot resolve the ethical issues – no responsible path forward unless a ban.

ASAN, 10-8-2019, "ASAN Comments on the Clinical Use of Human Germline Genome Editing", Autistic Self Advocacy Network, https://autisticadvocacy.org/2019/10/asan-comments-on-the-clinical-use-of-human-germline-genome-editing/, 6-27-2022, //ms

There is no responsible path forward for the use of germline genome editing at all. The procedure has potentially racist and strikingly ableist implications which would negatively impact the long-term future of the international disability rights community. As such, no international oversight structures could make any path forward for germline genome editing ethical or responsible. Additionally, it is quite unlikely that an international oversight structure would be fully able to govern germline genome editing. For example, although the United Nations or another international body could develop a Convention on the Ethical Use of Germline Genome Editing, countries could simply choose not to sign and/or ratify the Convention. Even if we assume that all interested countries signed and ratified such a document, international standards, even when binding, can remain unenforced. For example, although a great many countries have signed and ratified the Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, very few of these countries have made substantial progress towards enforcing Article 12 of the Convention, which requires that States Parties take “appropriate measures to provide access by persons with disabilities to the support they may require in exercising their legal capacity.” Some individual countries are also quite likely to interpret any international governing standards such as to allow whatever action they take, regardless of whether the standards actually do so. Regardless of the presence or absence of international standards, individual organizations or persons will exist who defy them, who will face little accountability.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.