Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cyber signaling and norms are impossible – NATO is unneeded

Ian Hurd, 19, (Ian Hurd, 4-23-2019, Houston Law Review, "If I Had a Rocket Launcher": Self-Defense and Forever War in International Law, https://houstonlawreview.org/article/7952-if-i-had-a-rocket-launcher-self-defense-and-forever-war-in-international-law, 6-26-2022) SCade

Its history can also be told through the changing uses of law in the political practice of justification. The legal formulations that were once thought to enclose war fully within self-evident and constraining legal categories have turned inside out and now operate to disperse military action throughout the world. As national interests and military technologies have changed, the rules have adapted, both in ratione temporis and ratione materiale. The instrumental utility of expansive self-defense claims for powerful governments is great, and the power of state practice to redefine international law is well-accepted—together these two facts ensure that the operative understanding of international rules will not deviate far from the desires of strong states. As the rule has moved, so has its political effects. Today it serves to legitimize and legalize the turn to “endless war” that has characterized American foreign policy since 2001. With self-defense now anchored on national security interests, it has released its former connections to time and to armed attack. From this new foundation, it became useful to ambitious governments who are eager to attack their enemies abroad. In self-defense defined as national security, these states found a legal justification that matched neatly with their new technologies of drones and cyber. Together, these tools encouraged those with the capabilities to engage in undeclared and perhaps never-ending military operations against those whom they see as enemies of the state. The history of self-defense helps to show the gap between the mythology of international law and its practical life. The myth says that international law provides a stable framework of rules that enable states to act toward their objectives while limiting their capacity to engage in acts that are damaging to the entire community. The reality is that rules become tools which powerful actors aim to use to their advantage. As Rebecca Sanders asserts, “There is nothing inherently progressive about legal culture[]” or international law.[82] The political effects of law depend on who is using it against what and against whom.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.