Banning germline genetic editing is naïve and amounts to ‘biological nonsense’ – their ‘ethical concerns’ are unlikely to ever occur and mystify legitimate implementation benefits
Pinker 15 Pinker, Steven. Steven Pinker is professor of psychology at Harvard University and the author of 10 books, most recently "The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person's Guide to Writing in the 21st Century." “Experts Debate: Are We Playing with Fire When We Edit Human Genes?” STAT, 17 Nov. 2015, www.statnews.com/2015/11/17/gene-editing-embryo-crispr/#Mathews. Accessed 30 June 2022. //DRE
Germline editing should be treated like any other medical procedure, weighing benefits against harms. It should not be banned out of a nebulous terror about tampering with a sacrosanct entity called "the human germline" - a concept which is biological nonsense. We affect the genetic makeup of our offspring, and the species, every time we choose one sex partner over another. And each of us introduces dozens of mutations into our own germlines by exposing ourselves to everyday radiation and chemical mutagens. Genetic editing would be a droplet in the maelstrom of naturally churning genomes. What are the potential benefits? There are several scenarios in which germline editing could benefit parents who carry disease genes. It could be used when both parents are homozygous for the disease, when in vitro fertilization doesn't produce enough viable and unaffected embryos for preimplantation genetic diagnosis, or if future data shows that babies who undergo the procedure have compromised longevity or health. The principal harm of germline editing is the risk of producing a sick or deformed child. Frankly, I suspect that this risk will always be unacceptable, so most of this discussion is moot. But suppose safety could be ensured. Should we fear the prospect of parents genetically enhancing their babies, the outcome the prohibitionists dread? This is highly unlikely - a relic of the early 1990s, when people thought there was "a gene for" this or that talent. We now know that heritable psychological traits, such as intelligence and personality, are the product of hundreds or thousands of genes, each with a tiny effect. And many genes have multiple effects, some of them harmful, such as an increased risk of neurological disease or cancer. With each enhancement providing a trifling benefit and a non-negligible risk, and with the editing process itself imposing risks, it's unlikely that today's morbidly risk-averse helicopter parents will take a chance at enhancing a child. They won't even feed their babies genetically modified applesauce! Add these risks to the expense and tribulation of IVF compared to good old-fashioned sex, and one can conclude that widespread genetic enhancement is too unlikely a possibility to worry about.