No valid legal human rights restriction on germline editing – ethical because right to health and to benefit from science.
Boggio and Yotova (2021). Gene editing of human embryos is not contrary to human rights law: A reply to Drabiak. Bioethics. doi:10.1111/bioe.12945
In a recent article in this journal, Katherine Drabiak argues that the genome editing of human embryos is contrary to fundamental human rights law.1 “Such practice,” Drabiak concludes, “would violate what we should recognize as a fundamental human right to inherit a genome without deliberate manipulation.” 2 Her argument is presented in the form of a critique of the analysis and conclusions reached by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics in its 2018 report Genome editing and human reproduction: Social and ethical issues3 and of the background paper, authored by Rumiana Yotova, on The regulation of genome editing and human reproduction under international law, EU law and comparative law. 4 Unfortunately, Drabiak's analysis mischaracterizes both the Nuffield Council's report and international human rights law that pertains to genome editing of human embryos. In this reply, we limit our critique to two main points. First, we challenge her methodological approach used to identify what constitutes “fundamental human rights law.” Her approach fails to include key human rights provisions in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, which include the right to health and the right to benefit from science. Second, we challenge the substantive standard invoked by Drabiak (a right to genetic integrity of a future person) and the implications of the concept of human dignity for informing how genome editing of human embryos can be regulated. After further analyzing Drabiak's argument and specifying what her argument does not prove, we conclude by reiterating the position taken by the Nuffield Council in 2018 and Yotova's background paper that: international law does not prohibit genome editing of human embryos and does not recognize a right to genetic integrity for future persons let alone inviolability as clearly evidenced in the text and preparatory works of the 1997 UNESCO Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights.5