Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Human dignity is not based on a certain genetic code.

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

To conclude that the existence of a non-manipulated genetic code is linked to human dignity, we would have to assume that human dignity is based on a certain genetic code, not any human genetic code but the one every person is born with. If that were true, any change to that code would carry a diminution of dignity. This conclusion is problematic because our genetic code changes during our lifetime. For instance, after a baby is born some fetal cells may be left behind in its mother’s body. They can travel to different organs and be absorbed into the mother’s tissues, changing her genetic composition,3 but no one would say that the mother is less worthy of dignity. In the case of blood transfusions, depending on the amount of white blood cells (the only ones that contain nuclear DNA), some DNA is transferred from the donor to the recipient, even in small amounts, and it can survive for days in his or her body,4 but this does not make the recipient less dignified during that transitory period. Furthermore, some diseases (such as cancer) can lead to acquired genetic mutations, creating the so-called genetic mosaics.5 In addition to being sick, do these people become undignified? The same happens in organ (Olszewski et al. 2005) and bone narrow donations.6 Both involve adding the donor’s DNA to extracts of tissues from the recipient, but none of these situations diminishes the recipient’s dignity. If the above thesis were true and if human dignity resided in a specific (human) genetic code, these examples would lead to the conclusion that some people lose their dignity during their lifetime due to changes (even if reduced and temporary) in their genomes, which obviously does not make any sense. Human dignity cannot be reduced to a certain genetic code, nor the human being reduced to genetic characteristics. This same idea is stated by article 2 of the UDHG: (a) Everyone has a right to respect for their dignity and for their rights regardless of their genetic characteristics. (b) That dignity makes it imperative not to reduce individuals to their genetic characteristics and to respect their uniqueness and diversity. If that is the case, there is no way that a change in the genetic features of a person will undermine his or her dignity.

Gene editing is ethical – does not clash with human dignity

Boggio and Yotova (2021). Gene editing of human embryos is not contrary to human rights law: A reply to Drabiak. Bioethics. doi:10.1111/bioe.12945 

Implicit in this interpretation of Article 6 is the fact that the protection of human embryos is not absolute. In fact, quite to the contrary, the HRC states that providing safe abortions is a duty of States under certain circumstances. Although merely hypothetical at this point, clinical applications of gene editing could conceivably remedy non‐viability and alleviate the mental pain or suffering that comes from knowing that the fetus is or may be affected by certain genetic conditions. Here we are not arguing that these interventions will have to be made available to patients as a matter of duty. More modestly, we argue that gene editing of human embryos does not clash with the right of life as codified in Article 6 of the ICCPR. In fact, it may reinforce it.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.