Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Human germline editing is not reminiscent of the type of eugenics we should be afraid of – potential for positivity and not harmful.

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

Human enhancement, including enhancement for health-related purposes, is rejected by many under the accusation that it led to the Nazi horrors and to other procedures to eliminate the unfit. What these measures have in common is that they are all eugenic measures (Paor and Blanck 2016), but the mistake is to consider all eugenics as pernicious. The Nazi Holocaust and the sterilization of mentally impaired people represented the negative side of eugenics, characterized by discrimination, hierarchization of human life, and ultimately the killing of those perceived as weak in our species (Bachruch 2004; Finkelstein and Stuart 1996). Conversely, the kind of human enhancement that we pursue today by means of gene editing (and artificial reproductive treatments) aims to promote the well-being of the existing generations (somatic genetic interventions) and of future generations (germinal genetic interventions). The assimilation between these two scenarios, so different from each other, rest on a misunderstanding about eugenics as being necessarily harmful (Caplan et al. 1999). Eugenics has been vilified because of its abuses during the early 20th century, particularly Germany’s choice to murder people with perceived disabilities. But the origin of eugenics was simply a desire to increase the odds that a child would be born healthy. Today we consider such measures as prenatal care, eating sensibly during pregnancy, avoiding use of alcohol or other drugs, and choosing your partner carefully to be the minimum that the pregnant woman should do and that the healthcare system should offer. Yet these practices are the very basis of eugenics. (Root 2000, 873). It has become common to use eugenics as a kind of bogeyman and for every intervention with connotations of human improvement to be at risk of being banned. However, we should not be afraid of eugenics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.