Germline gene editing enhances human dignity and isn’t eugenics – we have the capacity to resolve mass human suffering
Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4
In light of this understanding, gene editing does not violate human dignity; on the contrary, it offers the individual more possibilities to assert his/her status as a human person and, therefore, to assert his/her dignity. The claim is unfounded that gene editing is a form of eugenics and therefore—ipso facto—repugnant. To be healthy, to live a life with less suffering, cannot be against human dignity. The accusation of eugenics has become commonplace—invoking the Nazi holocaust and the fear of gross violations of human rights. However, the fear of past mistakes cannot block genetic ameliorations that are able to relieve humanity from diseases that continue to kill so many people. Critics also invoke the immutability of the genetic code, as a kind of foundation of human dignity. Nevertheless, the preservation of humankind’s genetic pool cannot be more important than the other values and goals at stake here, such as eradicating the pathological features of people who are suffering. If the aim is to avoid human suffering in present and future generations, the hypothetical right to receive an unmodified genetic code (hypothetical because future generations do not have any rights) cannot prevail over the right to health. On the other hand, an immutable genome cannot be viewed as a condition sine qua non for the dignity of the person. Scientific reports have shown that a person’s genetic code changes throughout their existence, even if such changes are subtle and temporary. Certainly, these changes do not imply a diminution of an individual’s dignity. Another repeated argument pertains to the destruction of our intrinsic human nature. However, enhancement (becoming stronger and healthier) is natural to humanity; it is the defining note of the human species. Looking back in time, the story of humankind has been one of enhancement. We are always trying to supplant ourselves (Buchanan 2011). We cannot assume that human nature is something defined and fixed (Fenton 2006). On the contrary, we cannot avoid changing ourselves for the simple reason that we are human. Gene editing is just another way of being human.