Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Deterrence doesn’t explain peace – nuclear powers are still engaged in war, non-nuclear powers attacking stronger states

Mack 11 {Andrew, Director of the Human Security Report Project, member of the School for International Studies (Simon Fraser University), Former Director of the Strategic Planning Office in the Executive Office of UN Secretary-General, Previously a professor and researcher at Harvard, the London School of Economics, UC Berkeley, and Fudan University, "A More Secure World?” CATO Unbound, 2/7, http://www.cato-unbound.org/2011/02/07/andrew-mack/more-secure-world}

A Nuclear Peace? For “realist” scholars, the absence of war between the major powers during the Cold War years is best explained by the existence of a stable balance of power between East and West—in particular by the deterrence created by the mutual possession of nuclear arsenals with “second strike” capacities. Kenneth Waltz, the leading proponent of the pacifying impact of nuclear weapons, has argued that, “Peace has become the privilege of states having nuclear weapons, while wars are fought by those who lack them.”[3] But while nuclear arsenals undoubtedly induced a measure of caution in the behaviour of the superpowers and their allies towards each other, Waltz’ assertion is wrong for two reasons. First, nuclear weapons states are not embroiled in fewer wars. Quite the contrary. Each of the four countries that have fought most international wars since the end of World War II—France, the United Kingdom, the United States, and Russia (USSR)—is a nuclear weapons state. Second, since the end of World War II, non-nuclear states have repeatedly attacked nuclear weapons states. U.S. nuclear weapons did not deter China from attacking U.S. forces in the Korean War, nor North Vietnam from attacking South Vietnam and U.S. forces in the 1960s. Israeli nuclear weapons did not dissuade Egypt from attacking Israel in 1973. British nuclear weapons did not deter Argentina from invading the Falkland Islands in 1982, and the Soviet nuclear arsenal did not deter the mujahedeen from waging war against the Soviet army in Afghanistan in the 1980s—nor did they prevent a Soviet defeat.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.