Ban fails – never been broad social consensus, and a benchmark for use is totally unrealistic.
Susan Scutti, CNN Updated 1803 GMT (0203 HKT) March 13, 2019 Proposal for global moratorium on editing of inherited DNA is met with criticism https://edition.cnn.com/2019/03/13/health/inherited-dna-editing-moratorium-study/index.html
director of the Progress Educational Trust, a nonprofit promoting public understanding of reproductive and genetic science, told the Science Media Centre that a new moratorium "is neither necessary nor useful." A moratorium would not have deterred Jiankui, said Norcross, who also had no role in the commentary. She added that he "acted secretively and in breach of a clear scientific consensus that germline genome editing should not be used in the clinic at this time." Even more, she believes that his practices were "scientifically and ethically unsound in so many different ways, that they would have been wrong regardless of whether or not they involved germline genome editing." Her nonprofit, which frequently organizes public events, has found "that people do not worry specifically about changing the germline," she said. "They are more concerned with whether or not specific applications of genome editing are medically warranted." O'Neill was skeptical for yet another reason: "There has never been a broad societal consensus about anything in any country, not even the allocation of human rights, so expecting this as a benchmark for clinical adoption of germline therapy is unrealistic."